I have started a new vote thread, hopefully addressing issues pointed out in this discussion.
Best, Alex On Thu, Jun 5, 2025 at 5:06 AM Henrik Ingo <hen...@nyrkio.com> wrote: > +1 > > Seems like Alexander did exactly that. > > In the meantime we spent some time with Alex to understand why poetry and > also uv actually create files with underscores, not hyphens, for the name > part of the filename: > > apache_otava-0.6.0-rc5.tar.gz > > Looking at random pypi.org packages, this really seems to be common: The > package name might be "soil-fertilizer", and you'd use it both in "npm > install soil-fertilizer" and https://pypi.org/project/soil-fertilizer > > However, the actual tar.gz and *.whl filenames change that to snake case: > soil_fertilizer-0.6.0.tar.gz > > We will of course use that format too. > > I've thought about it and I think the project name guidelines I read were > referring to some kind of official name of a package, and my conjecture > that also the tar archive name should follow the same rules was naive. To > summarize what we see happening: > - You are free to use - _ and capital letters in your project name, as you > prefer > - npm and other tools, will force that to "soil-fertilized" > - build tools like poetry will produce files where hyphens have been > forced to become underscores: soil_fertilizer-0.1.0... > - It's worth noting that "import soil-fertilizer" isn't valid python > syntax. So in the code, snake case is more useful. > > henrik > > On Thu, Jun 5, 2025 at 9:34 AM Mick Semb Wever <m...@apache.org> wrote: > > > > But I would consider using the word "incubating" either in the > > > authors or description fields, or both: > > > > > > description = "Apache Otava Incubator project: Change Detection for > > > Continuous Performance Engineering" > > > authors = ["Apache Otava Incubator <dev@otava.apache.org>"] > > > > > > > > > Yes please do. > > It shows you're following the intent of clearly labelling the project and > > these versions as currently part of the Apache Incubator. > > > > Given that the pypi/ files are only convenience artefacts, and won't be > > part of the post-vote /dist asf download, do you have a script ready for > > post-vote to upload those pypi/ files from their dev svn location to > pypi ? > > >
