Julien Le Dem created PIG-2698:
----------------------------------
Summary: org.apache.pig.test.TestMRCompiler should be rewritten to
actually verify the result is correct
Key: PIG-2698
URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/PIG-2698
Project: Pig
Issue Type: Improvement
Reporter: Julien Le Dem
right now it compares the text representation of the MR plan to "golden" files.
Some of them contain the serialized representation of the physical plan.
example:
{noformat}
| |---b:
Load(/tmp/input2:org.apache.pig.backend.hadoop.executionengine.mapReduceLayer.MergeJoinIndexer('org.apache.pig.builtin.PigStorage','kmonaaafhdhcaabdgkgbhggbcohfhegjgmcoebhchcgbhjemgjhdhehiibncbnjjmhgbjnadaaabejaaaehdgjhkgfhihaaaaaaaabhhaeaaaaaaabhdhcaaeogphcghcogbhagbgdgigfcohagjghcogcgbgdglgfgogecogigbgegpgphacogfhigfgdhfhegjgpgogfgoghgjgogfcohagihjhdgjgdgbgmemgbhjgfhccohagmgbgohdcofagihjhdgjgdgbgmfagmgbgoaaaaaaaaaaaaaaabacaaacfkaaangfgogeepggebgmgmejgohahfheemaaafgphagngbhaheaacdemgphcghcpgbhagbgdgigfcphagjghcpgjgnhagmcphfhegjgmcpenhfgmhegjengbhadlhihcaacfgphcghcogbhagbgdgigfcohagjghcogjgnhagmcohagmgbgocoephagfhcgbhegphcfagmgbgoimlohdjmoaemmdgiacaaaiemaaakgneghcgpgnefgeghgfhdhbaahoaaademaaafgnelgfhjhdheaaapemgkgbhggbcphfhegjgmcpengbhadlemaaahgnemgfgbhggfhdheaabaemgkgbhggbcphfhegjgmcpemgjhdhedlemaaaegnephahdhbaahoaaafemaaaggnfcgpgphehdhbaahoaaagemaaaognfdgpggheeghcgpgnefgeghgfhdhbaahoaaademaaamgnfdgpgghefegpefgeghgfhdhbaahoaaademaaaignfegpefgeghgfhdhbaahoaaadhihahdhcaacbgphcghcogbhagbgdgigfcohagjghcogjgnhagmcohfhegjgmcoenhfgmhegjengbhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaacacaaabemaaaegnengbhahbaahoaaafhihahdhcaabbgkgbhggbcohfhegjgmcoeigbhdgiengbhaafahnkmbmdbgganbadaaacegaaakgmgpgbgeeggbgdhegphcejaaajhegihcgfhdgigpgmgehihadpeaaaaaaaaaaaamhhaiaaaaaabaaaaaaaaahihdhbaahoaaakdpeaaaaaaaaaaaamhhaiaaaaaabaaaaaaaabhdhcaacegphcghcogbhagbgdgigfcohagjghcogjgnhagmcohagmgbgocoephagfhcgbhegphcelgfhjaaaaaaaaaaaaaaabacaaacekaaacgjgeemaaafhdgdgphagfheaabcemgkgbhggbcpgmgbgoghcpfdhehcgjgoghdlhihaaaaaaaaaaaaaaagiheaaafhdgdgphagfhdhcaafjgphcghcogbhagbgdgigfcohagjghcogcgbgdglgfgogecogigbgegpgphacogfhigfgdhfhegjgpgogfgoghgjgogfcohagihjhdgjgdgbgmemgbhjgfhccogfhihahcgfhdhdgjgpgoephagfhcgbhegphchdcofaepfahcgpgkgfgdheaaaaaaaaaaaaaaabacaaagfkaaaogjhdfahcgpgkgfgdhefegpefgogefkaaakgphggfhcgmgpgbgegfgefkaabfhahcgpgdgfhdhdgjgoghecgbghepggfehfhagmgfhdfkaabehcgfhdhfgmhefdgjgoghgmgffehfhagmgfecgbghejaaaihdhegbhcheedgpgmemaaahgdgpgmhfgngohdheaabfemgkgbhggbcphfhegjgmcpebhchcgbhjemgjhdhedlhihcaagcgphcghcogbhagbgdgigfcohagjghcogcgbgdglgfgogecogigbgegpgphacogfhigfgdhfhegjgpgogfgoghgjgogfcohagihjhdgjgdgbgmemgbhjgfhccogfhihahcgfhdhdgjgpgoephagfhcgbhegphchdcoefhihahcgfhdhdgjgpgoephagfhcgbhegphcaaaaaaaaaaaaaaabacaaaahihcaaemgphcghcogbhagbgdgigfcohagjghcogcgbgdglgfgogecogigbgegpgphacogfhigfgdhfhegjgpgogfgoghgjgogfcohagihjhdgjgdgbgmemgbhjgfhccofagihjhdgjgdgbgmephagfhcgbhegphcaaaaaaaaaaaaaaabacaaalfkaaafgbgdgdhfgnfkaaangjgohahfheebhehegbgdgigfgeejaabehcgfhbhfgfhdhegfgefagbhcgbgmgmgfgmgjhdgnecaaakhcgfhdhfgmhefehjhagfemaaafgbgmgjgbhdhbaahoaaaoemaaafgjgohahfheheaablemgphcghcpgbhagbgdgigfcphagjghcpgegbhegbcpfehfhagmgfdlemaaaggjgohahfhehdhbaahoaaagemaaangmgjgogfgbghgffehcgbgdgfhcheaachemgphcghcpgbhagbgdgigfcphagjghcphagfgocphfhegjgmcpemgjgogfgbghgffehcgbgdgfhcdlemaaahgphfhehahfhehdhbaahoaaagemaaakhagbhcgfgohefagmgbgoheaafaemgphcghcpgbhagbgdgigfcphagjghcpgcgbgdglgfgogecpgigbgegpgphacpgfhigfgdhfhegjgpgogfgoghgjgogfcphagihjhdgjgdgbgmemgbhjgfhccphagmgbgohdcpfagihjhdgjgdgbgmfagmgbgodlemaaadhcgfhdheaaeeemgphcghcpgbhagbgdgigfcphagjghcpgcgbgdglgfgogecpgigbgegpgphacpgfhigfgdhfhegjgpgogfgoghgjgogfcphagihjhdgjgdgbgmemgbhjgfhccpfcgfhdhfgmhedlhihcaacbgphcghcogbhagbgdgigfcohagjghcogjgnhagmcohagmgbgocoephagfhcgbhegphcaaaaaaaaaaaaaaabacaaabemaaaegnelgfhjheaacgemgphcghcpgbhagbgdgigfcphagjghcpgjgnhagmcphagmgbgocpephagfhcgbhegphcelgfhjdlhihahbaahoaaapaaaappppppppdchahahahahahahdhcaaecgphcghcogbhagbgdgigfcohagjghcogcgbgdglgfgogecogigbgegpgphacogfhigfgdhfhegjgpgogfgoghgjgogfcohagihjhdgjgdgbgmemgbhjgfhccofcgfhdhfgmheaaaaaaaaaaaaaaabacaaacecaaamhcgfhehfhcgofdhegbhehfhdemaaaghcgfhdhfgmheheaabcemgkgbhggbcpgmgbgoghcpepgcgkgfgdhedlhihaachaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahdhbaahoaaaaaaaaaaabhhaeaaaaaaakhdhcaabbgkgbhggbcogmgbgoghcoejgohegfghgfhcbcockakephibihdiacaaabejaaafhggbgmhfgfhihcaabagkgbhggbcogmgbgoghcoeohfgngcgfhcigkmjfbnaljeoailacaaaahihaaaaaaaaahihihdhbaahoaaaaaaaaaaabhhaeaaaaaaakhbaahoaablhihdhbaahoaaakdpeaaaaaaaaaaaamhhaiaaaaaabaaaaaaaabhbaahoaablhbaahoaaaphihdhbaahoaaaaaaaaaaaahhaeaaaaaaakhihdhbaahoaaaihdhbaahoaaakdpeaaaaaaaaaaaamhhaiaaaaaabaaaaaaaaahihdhbaahoaaaihdhbaahoaaakdpeaaaaaaaaaaaamhhaiaaaaaabaaaaaaaaahihdhbaahoaaaihdhbaahoaaakdpeaaaaaaaaaaaamhhaiaaaaaabaaaaaaaaahiaahahi','','b','scope','true'))
- scope-102
{noformat}
This is not very useful has:
- it breaks whenever there's a change to the physical plan. Related or not to
what this is "testing"
- opening the file does not help with debugging.
- "fixing" it requires regenerating the files from the current result without
knowing if it's correct or not
the test should instead check only the part of the plan that is is supposed to
check to be useful
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
If you think it was sent incorrectly, please contact your JIRA administrators:
https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/ContactAdministrators!default.jspa
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira
