Hi,

we are currently checking the Open Source Compliance of Apache Poi 5.0.0 and if 
we can use it in our commercial software.
We found two problems, which may can be resolved somehow:


  1.  org/apache/poi/sl/draw/BitmapImageRenderer.java
     *   Method: readImage
     *   There is a comment with a stackoverflow link and there are several 
lines of code which are completely equal with the suggested solution from 
stackoverflow
     *   Problem: Code on Stackoverflow is published under the Creative Commons 
Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International Public License, which is kind of a 
problem
     *   Solution: remove the stackoverflow link and maybe rewrite the code a 
little bit
  2.  org/apache/poi/util/StringCodepointsIterable.java
     *   The file/class is basically a copy of 
https://gist.github.com/EmmanuelOga/48df70b27ead4d80234b which is also 
mentioned in the comment above the class declaration
     *   Problem: There is no license, copyright, etc. for this code which is 
technically a violation of the copyright
     *   Solution: ??

If I am wrong somehow, please correct me. But my colleague who detected these 
findings has many years of consulting experience in open source compliance.

KR Stefan

Reply via email to