The vote is now closed. There were 14 +1 votes and no other votes, meaning the proposal was passed.
I will approach Infra in the days ahead about implementing the commit hook. Robbie On 14 February 2011 16:53, Robbie Gemmell <[email protected]> wrote: > For those who didn't follow the recent discussion, I recently raised > the issue of our poor use of JIRA and inclusion of JIRA references > within svn commit log messages. A quick check of the prior 3 months > commits showed barely over 30% of them had a JIRA reference, which is > far lower than it should have been. > > During the discussion I suggested we add a pre-commit hook to enforce > use of JIRA references where appropriate. One suggestion I made was > that this would block all commits that don't have a Qpid JIRA > reference unless they instead contained eg 'NO-JIRA', which could be > used to bypass the hook on demand. Any commit which failed to meet > these cases would be rejected with a message alerting the committer > how to resolve the issue, i.e. include a JIRA reference if appropriate > or signal their intent to bypass the requirement. This means noone > would ever be prevented from committing what they want when they want, > but still removes the possibility of JIRA references being left out > due to merely forgetting them, and means that if/when we later review > the commits we can identify where people have chosen to purposely > bypass the requirement. > > I haven't seen any objections to such a system, but to ensure everyone > gets a say I wanted to call this vote to establish the way forward. As > per indication at http://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html the > vote will be conducted on a majority rules basis, and I propose that > the vote is open equally to all committers and not just PMC members. > The vote will close at 5pm GMT on Thursday 17th February (i.e. approx > 72hrs from now). > > Please reply with your +1 / -1 vote, or cross one of the boxes below: > > [ ] +1, I accept the proposal and vote to add the svn pre-commit > hook as outlined above. > [ ] -1, I reject the proposal and vote not to add the svn pre-commit > hook outlined above. > > > Regards, > Robbie > --------------------------------------------------------------------- Apache Qpid - AMQP Messaging Implementation Project: http://qpid.apache.org Use/Interact: mailto:[email protected]
