I tested the 0.18 release and all-in-all it works pretty fine.
The performance on H2 still is an issue of course but not blocking (RAVE-838).
Also, RAVE-845 seems to be fixed, deleting a user with friend associations now works.

However I discovered a new, and IMO worse error RAVE-859: when I delete a user who has pages shared with, that action also deletes those shared pages which aren't 'owned' by this user. Rather destructive...

I'm not sure we should qualify this as a release blocker, as we already canceled the previous release candidate, but *functionally* it certainly qualifies. I don't know if anyone (yet) is using this feature in an (almost) production environment, but if so then they should *not* upgrade to this 0.18 release candidate until this bug is fixed. Or, well, maybe previous releases also had this bug already (I haven't had time to check) in which case it doesn't really matter.

WDYT: should we accept this as a known/recognized bug (and then highlight this in the release announcement) or qualify this as a release blocker?

I'm holding off voting +1/-1 for now.

Ate


On 12/02/2012 05:34 AM, Raminderjeet Singh wrote:
Discussion thread for vote on 0.18 release candidate.

For more information on the release process, checkout -
http://www.apache.org/dev/release.html

Some of the things to check before voting are:
- can you run the demo binaries
- can you build the contents of source-release.zip and svn tag
- do all of the staged jars/zips contain the required LICENSE and NOTICE files
- are all of the staged artifacts signed and the signature verifiable
- is the signing key in the project's KEYS file and on a public server


Reply via email to