Hi Craig,
Thanks for your reply and checking. Firstly, PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK of key ID C8ADAD3A which exists in `KEYS-FILE`[1] is correct. Secondly, key ID C8ADAD3A is not https://keyserver.pgp.com/, for there is no search result of my email, i.e panj...@apache.org . How about trying again to load keys from `KEYS-FILE`[1] ? Does anyone have idea about this issue? [1] https://dist.apache.org/repos/dist/dev/incubator/shardingsphere/KEYS Juan Pan panj...@apache.org Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere On 11/18/2019 09:02，Craig Russell<apache....@gmail.com> wrote： I'm having trouble downloading the public key from the KEYS file. Does this KEYS file look right? Craig gpg --verify apache-shardingsphere-incubating-4.0.0-RC3-src.zip.asc gpg: assuming signed data in 'apache-shardingsphere-incubating-4.0.0-RC3-src.zip' gpg: Signature made Sun Nov 10 22:43:40 2019 PST using RSA key ID C8ADAD3A gpg: requesting key C8ADAD3A from https server keyserver.pgp.com gpgkeys: no key data found for https://keyserver.pgp.com/ gpg: no valid OpenPGP data found. gpg: Total number processed: 0 gpg: keyserver communications error: Not found gpg: keyserver communications error: Bad public key gpg: Can't check signature: No public key [MacBook-Pro-10:~/Downloads] clr% gpg --recv-keys < KEYS-2.txt [MacBook-Pro-10:~/Downloads] clr% cat KEYS-2.txt -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- Version: GnuPG v1 mQINBFyR/WgBEACuVDJ2aFMc+GvOcvBA2CpgIM5AwWo3ES2WxcWuNoBHugZvtmQ0 Rhq0HigPcXD7F7J6Xh6PCs80EJxvbczQ16wi9597s1rzHbHFxueX8GKNtVyg7+NG /INzhDEEvaVE0ChxOGpSgZ8vnGZe5ERbLaW9e+onFvah5/poWiHKUJAlsvbgV4tB mmBCxIeTjdxHsdCFQYKpK1MNToTvSvgLZBIcNZ1OTTQMRFRDkoEfU0HR19naqHtW Mv87as4nxlnI4Du85tYdv6DbzL7qqFUNWUh+SROCdzReyWZiVrHzaP+zywtCnbjO /ddVo+lnMEesoFEdVnhRqCrtpYJuvSeIt+YkojCJtL+hooqgDcmXxlwRKOftY5ic ISXnriT8OE1cuUi8ghyl9YefZmjlyz+S7kCNJV81ZCi1/Uxan+yXxx4mxRn3fL61 hm51NPEghA+plWLLXylRFlRXYuwnUvOIMk1p5gx7Il3xfmtQ+cLC2dclN85viaaC avbMUQDEp1qGn6K/tKIZSF+CAViCCNg2ZgHxgimLNFkvK6TfUsvBNj/oPC18+H4+ l6+0Ub8TXb9XzRL2CcJ/I6uuifkABOuAPE2ObK2+K/yL5sQX2/qZuZotClHHWBqE idwChmt52ygbLwiOxQGcy6Rbv3A72WCZmbW+7f7i7iRE3x8w5HAjdDYbpwARAQAB tDhaaGFuZyBMaWFuZyAoYXBhY2hlIHJlbGVhc2UgYXdzKSA8emhhbmdsaWFuZ0Bh cGFjaGUub3JnPokCOAQTAQIAIgUCXJH9aAIbAwYLCQgHAwIGFQgCCQoLBBYCAwEC HgECF4AACgkQWfbgE3AOYGVdMg//W+DeSXux1j7uTfpgZ/NpBL/GDQPmxDVfredC xBuFtyGhX4HszPHXaSHtBZ69PcfjEPXM0Cs3+U+FR6Idkh4dorxwt+vcgD1PIInm 4wQaT6WGwbWboBuYpNqd833lAkykz0J881JtoGSPLA2llV/edOYlHOGTqV+Hbyym o136xlp8BcjhiKFK8j8a1ayUN7OOijTVFVZVpjLXw5zekqaPjYz7BOVvYeNu/27F +sUWszEGzrrC0TsM1pm48fGVClVy4x9UX9uMYjuWUL1sSepOfE8JMvDo2F4JyePw yS5KCqM5/hSSAh2NzlhgsBi997idNaKobCyQhbmCBgWW27KiOPMEmpk7hOCw5piT cVznTwlLAip4Jm7X2feEltlSWIrgPmuEliLdEPzTaNz6DLHaLRApvv1vmgcg42cn sckVq4zlXO7Ia3xP3H7gxxtM4i4MdkThbVF+iUd8wWmUOdA0iWg5eyrSoxfDJ2kE K68vZIxwKvEiXG7Eei2UNRka7/CzSj/rH8IIgcSV2bvxin/c/01/xf0dJj7vUSqF MNXkDkij2U2kX5r27bPZLQXqIqigga/ytqxWluvTIitXaiXgY2vEqWd/AMWYY07Y ZdX0fXoJIvLXndi4Y2M1YWCsB9T4gqzr2PP55c7/L2lrxa6gYK1Tg9vY20GhmdSh WbF24c65Ag0EXJH9aAEQANhKpqL/X6w32ud4/Y4COZtnfn7W8tDwNl5v37aez98w jm+WK+/QukKno0wlcSdAhKwg5vTJUiDqRse5Uo8auLVInFCHOyYknpE6bbiz/b8k NmXKGYsM3UGLDVuoBDXqH0ThFCEAiNCud+bcuOspIbLiYLWeI7732C3lbXUZJnsR XgybO4+SBYlB4lm9XfcdSFBss9mdLikqJsLAkB+2nRBZKcvamJqML3pjAr/Ps7Te gW7KvPedPHY/0CV1iqSTPB5KE1WelYm6hOmjL8MfnlXna8rgO/9Oh2D2pKydYbhs kY0JmURQuP/KnIiJt2th096JWftQAWZvmF7XYwBS82ZReQzqj/VGPZQgO1UBUR3v ZIHXzfm/fuA9UtT8BZCUJSgkDL3nkVuHWTVt+HkealBxqjGZj5Y+S6XXwhfNnqYA U0oADAoB3rqnmRyhP8A266NxA+2MkZ8YERHG9GY0FIa3Oe2U6AWXMfxB2NwGx/5X X4iKTSD2uvk5QFw8F7/F8aovh0D0kttCxGR8G6ZMY5HxMNSVyWiK257QNWkTl4xO xHmLUvECwKlpCwfzCL/N8A6xv4iux+PO8SzYRcKKx41wvS13AN0N3YFA8OPe0HNH cJM9xgQ1pksxAjxM4z/7xh4NU1v2XlpG5trbIYmDMHQR77bPpkXLe/c4xiTVU4dP ABEBAAGJAh8EGAECAAkFAlyR/WgCGwwACgkQWfbgE3AOYGUnNQ/8CAleXdzC8dkx 20Ph8vQvXn3poURZMftFeL8nnPp0Rx5KlBYe5Fvkldbv4lz7p6XTEDUfzy7fpZAC PjHVCuT4RUIsDMUPqjruhQuo7dFJqT9Pe692msk0PkqjvkXvW/TwfGNrGd6IYjpz /GY7xtTzxrnrzYk0E/s+E0Zr0nA7VZYwbQtVT2+jYn4TKYWJ/CXP87BoE05IrY2Q DEQn1zCapjdiyo/5UlyXKp4LrqQqoaFhNvGUa5teZ6wOwX/T/uM0ijLemvGq3mAd 8v1elh7gHnxQJ1qLGStXS/CrsR6JO9QE0/AfI18wLs7tDZoAL+tThmBy9CyfSAko F6YBKaCNc9zZyoutFAkBQClUZXRof2PkYMGKcNDeoHpA9o5AXJPAO9iOkU+JRb+a j4YRM1iGiG83wLIhvuI8d3HiczaRKp2LWu7MOK+0FfOdfswzXl1UHLphSWcKlbwJ mDkhcE/7k84Fd2EHSfravtUcfpcauL2+2f+H3x3FQqYxYbP9yQusmB8Bq4x+Ukcs YSzWnELUjHxXlI+fCgOOc7DF90ffPlg8LVo24O436HF1Cyl7izX2pIWnENmLVh8H 33W6DBs1QGh293phN+CBYInxYjn8X12RuCOvQeFAJVXlJSK58SLSKvf81DWmAbu/ iX3+DXBQeKKl6cZZOAKjhVtG7X0SDjE= =89x7 -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- Version: GnuPG v1 mQINBFyFx0kBEADHUr5MvL2qZKxcIeN31OoMhbOipk131IFzp+k4wob1GwGTai+t n18pEkWKXACWTdBgk+QggAb78uh0Z1+otlB3x6W9IoFf4rxc6xAKKlveYEF2lnaw r/hvIzNYcleR3watbnMls0zHTQm0VsF7ZeDZ2UAWBZFy5+O9UZMgTvSiSOumNrFp pq6u8mrC/8p+WbcqYZLuB5t5aHkMuWgLFEpnlbCU5vlOohl0XNyvg8iu/uR+KT7P kzUu8KtUgyYcC0vywlBeCe3FE7vQ3MEg5VkiNd7jArkDmiWmQQyJbeMbLXHUXQhN uXk/UvIZ9QUKiW50A+iSCdiHPVxxpJS5bRflvdTiUMmW8bnnPqnw1ELoHcVDKNra aykuOQtLJxMpRfHgtzA1Si9bkXeDvRNmUyqbmXcq/UjHfGjg6UOKJvXrHQ20fPn2 4U0YiGBtwhIyZ9m0TbdS82HLNlixeBbkEWG1uzF3a72xMmg1EHvnS9h0mMy2KF93 hkdaWFujSRjGi5LPT76EO6zv8WH+73wd4uVVRuHB5z6MbtQRD5iP4u8Bm4azk1IQ cPQ83oViM69BV5t8pjIfhLTjLEhpp7KdO/3fcu8bJxOMCHExp9fSsoH97bWxdVtN 51liD/ENDJrt4E0XwuyZtzFG++X+N6mRWly8ny564tv7zlQsjBLQH6ACNwARAQAB tDl6aGFuZ3lvbmdsdW4gKENPREUgU0lHTklORyBLRVkpIDx6aGFuZ3lvbmdsdW5A YXBhY2hlLm9yZz6JAk4EEwEIADgWIQQJXg0hvCjPx6i4B2333yjSN6gEjAUCXIXH SQIbAwULCQgHAgYVCgkICwIEFgIDAQIeAQIXgAAKCRD33yjSN6gEjAURD/0dTJnC MNWBV2q9HYKxIyYdI4/Niae8L/a67i96zft58TOYp88U3Fhvm4Ve7zk7ip2GpR+x eoE9UUsbRZlRORNs2zdwze2JwTi/Ex3p2HjtsMqdqh8BhinbDgFMyfA9o+6E+xUO Hc1gMprIS5Biwj2GEEHm9fWIkWzdbpnkxEd329+ujn5nDWPJsVW8nIjxZPDQqkQ8 Gm+Dn+wsgKFGp8PR8EP3Mx36tyKRbMYbJ8Mj/7uDGPilJ/wr/PJB7c5arvFt1HtQ 8DKGoTwC4sa59hemAhF/4JuekfrCbBGgAER95aSlJDZbMiV+Lj2fOVprCDoIJMeC Gm4LpT78PjdvTh+7bwV+GbVrw+pFIH+PHRiXmAaMqgrHUa6WEqb0wWfsj4ISZuop 27oJAYm/xjWYJI8tWfeMUklAQwsoLXfVvuTMYHRSe72hDRTKEkA7je9jB3FmeRa4 V5bhWABQwbX2hzd361nM3wykNlUOHADy4lOnLC6wC39Be+Vz3QtfXELp7788dWOc 89egLqq8Sd6dtJ1/ngJGgwW6RA3djNszq7W+01py9yzZfGOp9ZrJNOPI6LRAIX/h te/AB/p9J96fWlkNwTfw5sDwEyU2e0tgEIkhSasySCXzck6bC3mMnFfNX5b/LaJu 0GWJeAqs2Q9HnhKwpz9+vRHdW6ypCF1A8+nrMrkCDQRchcdJARAAsPNPCwgM2B1N fccJ0Pw+CdsJfvqklwv3An/Sef1T3ZmvTN92iKR2YJGUqtrJgJB4bvuaPT5eMvsC pnTwL+tLmrApkiYA+ltrMoD98u3WmIaEfIpjztzRZ5MO714XVFnP4MjN+c/cH2tY BwoHdfISdLt5km7vh/z3wmZnT6OsxLe+Wyb52YgDbX0LtHN7J7pdfajm4MWBznKL gQVY8jEhVLnJDbvuUx0vQhl9ggAryXYk0DmhSIB11HFsgIHR9eHIVi4uRzyu3CK6 0VLtBV9KtahrqvlnMwosWB2OrhDUkJ55HPb/+qtXLtswGHHalz6u5f7/SgSBh8zM SgbdYmrpYW+qRXkbcoyVwDTW2A/qWc1hbrldo4gsMSDf/wpBn7j6FHiaeTawJsDs LTvr6+sW1vA+Cyb5wPvNoqjYcrzjuSkE3GilsA2ChlWAkXPp2yNxPd0FprthQixc c9B+AaolIpXPkjtAZSAAl2qhFY6wt2MyBk7iv4N/WR5Zd7IT92smzbo0BiY8nrE2 J7ZcmIWu4Jkb6Cg80mrS35dXEqFdywm2HPAuQmatg9XrV9FWkDCRLmaK0eiU0vhT ZweUzXz8mi0juV/cg7UIXb1rTSVaQ7r4uL4mmmN+l5GULeczlO0k3rREH5c/9257 D+nYNA8HIjV/UWD/Nkx1CATZWgJHuVEAEQEAAYkCNgQYAQgAIBYhBAleDSG8KM/H qLgHbfffKNI3qASMBQJchcdJAhsMAAoJEPffKNI3qASMprgP/0dJkRJtuEX76342 qgbsN/b6eJi4X/WWdBQMaTAinUanKfbdHm8seWYf/tKdtBDXBCdv7p6/Hum5DCN8 rFQJH+/W5QVEnIxwMOqxFRcimEmRPgbQskSHAtbAIwG4xhvUzm05HHuu0+2++RLr glwpNXxZaFzZiNzGdbzXAnznNsgLf9Gui3YSWUDTq5nklk0XQb+1pDJ2akyM76j3 jhNHgZtwyW8lJ5kPHGTRYH3gANWmOtF2FrPH3Bp1vHK0vuNrkQM5jNssXHCYgjqe LiDbyJPQ2B327Kf+KDH65B3COVw81QtIOjT2mT23TAbQp/RFsUeg8kb6nPecaGHG e+iTFhhpXCfx3lGx0JTzQcnYO0KE6d93t54DTmwx64QP6yqoadu51sPxFP9bZjq2 0jFBkUyoxBQa3hlK2gUEOBW96k6Ml0+MkANounIl4c+2+zT9LjHrAF9XCWl6YYym ew5XXOX8tZd0QCfmbEswt35iZtGVskovm4EXG6OReyFa5NZlZmLWe5AiWQgeePCT bCbfMjpfrqVtRrQUiS5LKRvZaQYgvQyITpQS9XXBRdutiIUzAM13cGBMpPOgAdGD GhJBPzEf3aO3FczPdQ0AURJRD7V0BEMBUJ7PeRjsa7ftOp7L4xcainH43+oX42qX KAMvNInYlUBZ8qQ6t+67i4Gxcn9i =I8Ox -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- mQINBF3A8H0BEADkEngQhny/mACzVjhl+oPBQp/u9auhD69f3vWWKkUxy1swRTV4 p1Fs5vUaVJnJiJyNlA1yiRTLOtyph4encJaet6PWKPmvwyTnQRbpmLUJRvFWdDia p3Q6oqknMJ/43bbdSO5r2RQtgKuVeRtmgPfW6RA71cqxdywacDK5E1V+T1jpiR6J HB0BKB50GButFFMIZgC8ReuP/NZdp5owm+eMjAnMpdTi3tgDHJieF0+0GzgkaUGl +QScIVT9PGzeKw3zqix534Bk54Pn3/aZK5Aw/1ik1AtQs2WDvR7UCZoZa7evoBJX I4EyjmxwKIYWbz5fiAk0Oe9qtUfrHZpDptIp8BE1nskNACKL3F/RBRZbjo0pTqvc SzIOFV9vOoNaf2CsWENNtj5tOfNvX0eUe3bCFaplotrVELeRgrpkZSraTSnKvibO brgfiwQvBCjyOC/y2E0WzNX1pJFvT7QVU9VFVShB8Oibg9rXrfHtMOBUsFrwNXPA lfq3mccnFgbCfvMFdIKAvrb07MtT4IvI+RIa93jzC1F6KkWqDrwDZIusWClcOhG1 96gGUDphdDiooU1RdcGdngtW1pQnYwSgEZnCBIXy1y4XTZlVZjF2jKzye0JC76eM eWhXSNOAApCeT0Na4OGQPSV5CRlRZlxq9PhXe0vEm7uOidEGzKvojTs4UwARAQAB tBxwYW5qdWFuIDxwYW5qdWFuQGFwYWNoZS5vcmc+iQJUBBMBCAA+FiEE0bO9wdNS uSdme7M3h/BRwcitrToFAl3A8H0CGwMFCQeGH4AFCwkIBwIGFQoJCAsCBBYCAwEC HgECF4AACgkQh/BRwcitrTqJ+RAAq95O0nXnWE+IRGXpKvMt7itxY+KymHQvpOVu XLoiS7cLfCRfgkogyY2StT77CHkBniQKq1XzxgDfswPWIoTO4SBtubrw6CueqZNM 4iAFPrKNRGas7DJmygxLo5ulN5aYS+E/sPPjlgJcLr2b5HCZs8+GczloovbcON9G yK2eczO4Iyfj6/zII2P7nqPuPrxyDdvi7DyedhCtRZuhFvTn9hZetgS5DvFD6IMM vZzMBo0mfF1JOkraTXGGW+aO9HPa2CU5wqE6Jo2qUimki6Z68xTmLIBO9zn8iyHW GYupgLY5mJeYG9MBLrCxL03hUOOoHZdJQEEHMZd0k0Q+HT2V7n3///59cLCMeNSn q1uKq0b2oRnMiSiNklLIhf14/ictCEDCjB+kVLFqkw6/mitsi1G0f3AA6/V8qBVJ pVv74aQC9kLiqY3AOfRFBI9XhXFz9bPVqXK3TnlMX1lIUe02Q5d1gUP/XJpQrvzP De969iZAjdLKy9BoO2OENTMhU6JiZ3FpWAw8EjbQ+YuuBEIg/a2yv4IaKu1Rtk/6 dEVwdlH6cONBDA4XFDOB5lhbgHpSp321FWwlfJjqJDx9HDeKAZ6Z/drINQaB1Bfc pRVFdEYxVqtvfd0Csc+ZDzFGnT+c6zO1asiPYTxUEzi+EaLz8EPT652w/g0Rg5yE xHJe1yW5Ag0EXcDwfQEQALBi3U/lcBJSNfOqom1UKnXbdlIClGtIT80OhYaN7Pm4 IivrhKzMTw00DI02DkMc52pJMkdiKKgBKzfl8WaYFBZ2mpmFDcjC/7d2w2R5Wrh9 1Kuxr6EuQJSlSVQXdCmO/BPosPDgbAIT+piW3YANXmpgiY4VdcIHufxrI0q15VrV 2iTvMED4dfz8JlH0YIX7lYVIzUa3amAaWG9f/ZqQHexNrVm4veVHVkqR9dDGwVVk x+H1J2e4YiT9cYF2v8tiQkCb5XQvzBYzHb81AEn4WcBmi/sfAr+nudCcYk7EiVFm hRw7prS/l/OJMnY2/sC5bP0TdXgjDtlNtyaIH8wIEEL4bzLyYtbio7lbx5L1tMHt CDpkM8h1+Zm35AKHsqKoBBNJCXODBHNNvURk04Ma69nlqpxhinXExdq2IWRGzJwX cJSJMgtx00GxIqgYdM9N9C9ok0SPrFyNFavNWObQJIwXEymQ3fvz0Nt1JwkezrHZ J8HbDfMuc8AJQtlUYI/aMQAGi5hnbjPH/7retOUlZKOCBXx9kW7J7q7uY+YKSmeE Hx4WNW6ZUz+qqTFiWty2V/XvAm4gcvYq1s0JBeBDh6x7/6K5/qD6U9JiqWruJeyO SInMx4lDZiw1Vt5gM+U7js0Ca/7UfSRfwfuSbk/bBK2uN7huVxjn8C6xONpRiARx ABEBAAGJAjwEGAEIACYWIQTRs73B01K5J2Z7szeH8FHByK2tOgUCXcDwfQIbDAUJ B4YfgAAKCRCH8FHByK2tOifgEACxXbO6Ed9Ywz8TsXyCJ1YYVKII5MrmmWUKbuIu 3eU3Bs6ErHMV/ABH1HvB6dI5L784/qiaYAJHwLFdK3sUxHN4xj9hJaNAkw9xTJQz DQoUzpl5LWOxWGOUcHu/QR9XaY6E7ACL3EG0B/2un7/RDQPNMJUOKZxFsIYamb+E GIYD+q/QrIdrVKtoDm690ahY08iNbi0z674zle2Qr3+Dt71OOPVRBLbEM7zSsVf0 bec38ZasTJyTA4pN3lmZ0R+Ql3FhS5p39yx3QgV/lJFbhvhqmTkrd93/nyz7YiXF qtGfLCy3CGjEQXWMtcqTvjedVrOQfphrkhT8ptF1S5p08OWQ5nvZGqVlyqqmNGd6 9+8VC1F0Xt3/uZiiT23NS6Chz+9opRe4C/pRmEwfgVfGr2avC+2Rrkx9+WBf22Op BS8c5Cq69Z10sP7IDA2FxS4zCc6ew7eSS8lBah5GfVIrG9P8MDL6+gV+brm024fu 7c8cYx8DO9BvjZQJRr+HC4RQWQK7Q+VpqcstzKkSxjRfnTl9pJmiHyM95lofxIlb r4f4hz6LZNyV/50SsBgYi8fEz0pBC3Lxa9q5nBOiriw6XQPwfycqMJAQavL/PGlR gbLmBSMlaY35JBfkqNzhJi2TguVng52addu0dsgBN3vEW0g5kUErw41RTbp4msks zFm46A== =TI+1 -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- On Nov 11, 2019, at 2:40 AM, Juan Pan <panj...@apache.org> wrote: Hi everyone, With the help and effort of our community, the previous issues were fixed already. I am glad to invite everyone to move on to check and vote for our 4.0.0-RC3 ROUND 4. Release notes: https://github.com/apache/incubator-shardingsphere/blob/dev/RELEASE-NOTES.md The release candidates: https://dist.apache.org/repos/dist/dev/incubator/shardingsphere/4.0.0-RC3/ Maven 2 staging repository: https://repository.apache.org/content/repositories/orgapacheshardingsphere-1027/org/apache/shardingsphere/ Git tag for the release: https://github.com/apache/incubator-shardingsphere/tree/4.0.0-RC3/ Release Commit ID: https://github.com/apache/incubator-shardingsphere/commit/78a67e8c088ffc0b6f0e2c7418b0217cdc3bb87d Keys to verify the Release Candidate: https://dist.apache.org/repos/dist/dev/incubator/shardingsphere/KEYS Look at here for how to verify this release candidate: https://shardingsphere.apache.org/community/en/contribute/release/ The vote will be open for at least 72 hours or until necessary number of votes are reached. Please vote accordingly: [ ] +1 approve [ ] +0 no opinion [ ] -1 disapprove with the reason Checklist for reference: [ ] Download links are valid. [ ] Checksums and PGP signatures are valid. [ ] DISCLAIMER is included. [ ] Source code artifacts have correct names matching the current release. [ ] LICENSE and NOTICE files are correct for each ShardingSphere repo. [ ] All files have license headers if necessary. [ ] No compiled archives bundled in source archive. Best wishes, Trista Juan Pan panj...@apache.org Juan Pan(Trista), Apache ShardingSphere Craig L Russell c...@apache.org
