[ 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SLING-1555?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
 ]

Eric Norman updated SLING-1555:
-------------------------------

          Description: 
It would be nice if the jackrabbit.usermanager bundle exposed OSGI service(s) 
that maps exactly the functionalities of the REST services, so that one can use 
their features also in a programmatic way. 

This can be useful if an application has to manage users and groups without 
having an explicit request object (ex: from an EventListener), or in the case a 
user has to manipulate his account (in this case he doesn't have an 
administrative account, so his requests are not permitted to modify users). 
Also i think that, in certain situations, it could be just cleaner and simpler 
to write a servlet or script that directly invoke the methods, instead of find 
the way to invoke the REST services.

I think a simple but exaustive way to achieve this can be the direct mapping of 
the REST services described in 
http://sling.apache.org/site/managing-users-and-groups-jackrabbitusermanager.html
 and 
http://sling.apache.org/site/managing-permissions-jackrabbitaccessmanager.html, 
only using well-known JCR classes.
For example, obtaining the users list could be as simple as getting the 
UserManager OSGI service and invoking a method like "public NodeIterator 
listUsers()", changing a permission could be achieved by getting the 
AccessManager OSGI service and invoking a method like "public void 
modifyPermission(String node_path, String principalId, String privilege_name, 
String privilege_value, String order)", and so on...

Perhaps the best way to standardize these services is a dedicated API that 
formalizes the underlying concepts (ex: User, Group, Privilege and 
NodeAccessControl... if you think it's the case, i could propose my own...), 
but i think the simple REST services mapping could already be a nice (and 
ready-to-go) feature for developers...



  was:
It would be nice if the jackrabbit.accessmanager and jackrabbit.usermanager 
bundles expose OSGI service(s) that maps exactly the functionalities of the 
REST services, so that one can use their features also in a programmatic way. 

This can be useful if an application has to manage users and permissions 
without having an explicit request object (ex: from an EventListener), or in 
the case a user has to manipulate his account (in this case he doesn't have an 
administrative account, so his requests are not permitted to modify users). 
Also i think that, in certain situations, it could be just cleaner and simpler 
to write a servlet or script that directly invoke the methods, instead of find 
the way to invoke the REST services.

I think a simple but exaustive way to achieve this can be the direct mapping of 
the REST services described in 
http://sling.apache.org/site/managing-users-and-groups-jackrabbitusermanager.html
 and 
http://sling.apache.org/site/managing-permissions-jackrabbitaccessmanager.html, 
only using well-known JCR classes.
For example, obtaining the users list could be as simple as getting the 
UserManager OSGI service and invoking a method like "public NodeIterator 
listUsers()", changing a permission could be achieved by getting the 
AccessManager OSGI service and invoking a method like "public void 
modifyPermission(String node_path, String principalId, String privilege_name, 
String privilege_value, String order)", and so on...

Perhaps the best way to standardize these services is a dedicated API that 
formalizes the underlying concepts (ex: User, Group, Privilege and 
NodeAccessControl... if you think it's the case, i could propose my own...), 
but i think the simple REST services mapping could already be a nice (and 
ready-to-go) feature for developers...



    Affects Version/s:     (was:  JCR Jackrabbit Access Manager 2.0.4)
             Assignee: Eric Norman
               Labels: api programmatically service usermanager  (was: 
accessmanager api programmatically service usermanager)
              Summary: UserManager permissions manipulation services API  (was: 
Users and permissions manipulation API)

Split the original issue into two defects to handle the services api for 
usermanager and accessmanager separately

> UserManager permissions manipulation services API
> -------------------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: SLING-1555
>                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SLING-1555
>             Project: Sling
>          Issue Type: Improvement
>          Components: API
>    Affects Versions: JCR Jackrabbit User Manager 2.1.0
>            Reporter: Fabrizio Scarcello
>            Assignee: Eric Norman
>              Labels: api, programmatically, service, usermanager
>
> It would be nice if the jackrabbit.usermanager bundle exposed OSGI service(s) 
> that maps exactly the functionalities of the REST services, so that one can 
> use their features also in a programmatic way. 
> This can be useful if an application has to manage users and groups without 
> having an explicit request object (ex: from an EventListener), or in the case 
> a user has to manipulate his account (in this case he doesn't have an 
> administrative account, so his requests are not permitted to modify users). 
> Also i think that, in certain situations, it could be just cleaner and 
> simpler to write a servlet or script that directly invoke the methods, 
> instead of find the way to invoke the REST services.
> I think a simple but exaustive way to achieve this can be the direct mapping 
> of the REST services described in 
> http://sling.apache.org/site/managing-users-and-groups-jackrabbitusermanager.html
>  and 
> http://sling.apache.org/site/managing-permissions-jackrabbitaccessmanager.html,
>  only using well-known JCR classes.
> For example, obtaining the users list could be as simple as getting the 
> UserManager OSGI service and invoking a method like "public NodeIterator 
> listUsers()", changing a permission could be achieved by getting the 
> AccessManager OSGI service and invoking a method like "public void 
> modifyPermission(String node_path, String principalId, String privilege_name, 
> String privilege_value, String order)", and so on...
> Perhaps the best way to standardize these services is a dedicated API that 
> formalizes the underlying concepts (ex: User, Group, Privilege and 
> NodeAccessControl... if you think it's the case, i could propose my own...), 
> but i think the simple REST services mapping could already be a nice (and 
> ready-to-go) feature for developers...

--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira

Reply via email to