I understand that I can commit to both the Gitbox repo as well as the linked 
Github repo now. The former works without further actions for the latter 2fa 
needs to be enabled on github and the account needs to be properly linked.
I am wondering which of the two URLs should be used within the pom.xmls?
For me it would rather be the native gitbox URL (as documented now in 
https://reference.apache.org/committer/git) instead of the Github one. Mostly 
because gitbox is controlled by the ASF Infra team while Github is not.
Also for documentation purposes we should always point to mainly the Apache one 
and mention the Github repo as an additional option.

With 
https://github.com/apache/sling-site/commit/2f5dbedefff3fcaa0639716d59c0806620337fd0
 the pubScmUrl has been changed from git-wip to Github. IMHO this should rather 
be the gitbox url as this allows every committer to publish, even if she/he has 
not yet  set-up the linking of the Github account. This makes publishing less 
error-prone as for the gitbox URL no further prerequisites need to be fulfilled 
and one can just commit with the Apache LDAP ID and password.

WDYT?
Konrad

Reply via email to