I'm +1 for modernization I just wanted to highlight the hurdles we need to overcome to reach there
SolrRequestHandler is the current framework that serves all requests in Solr. This also has associated ways to - register end points and configuration - manage lifecycle - collect metrics - enforce security - logging - tracing - etc etc Introducing a new framework will have to deal with all of the above. For instance the JAX-RS is used you will start using web.xml to register your JAX-RS endpoints. --Noble On Mon, Dec 6, 2021 at 6:11 AM David Smiley <dsmi...@apache.org> wrote: > Just a simple +1 of support to modernization efforts in general. It's > encouraging to see that Jason & Eric had some fun together on this. > Modernization, I think, helps with the fun of any open-source project, and > thus helps keep everyone interested in continuing and reviewing interest in > Solr. If we/others feel we can't make fundamental changes, then I think > our interests (and that of contributors) will wane. Personally, I really > enjoy refactoring codebases, even if it may not seem sexy to some. > > I don't think we can rush into a SIP before more research/POC is tried. > It's too abstract at this stage. We don't even know what framework to use > yet ;-) > -- ----------------------------------------------------- Noble Paul
