Quoting Keith Ivey <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:

List Mail User wrote:

Legitimate domains will use wildcards for 'NS', 'MX' and even
occasionally for some more obscure records, but an 'A' or 'CNAME'
record is nearly always a spammer.

Do you have any statistics for that?  I administer plenty of domains
that have wildcard A records, and I'm not a spammer.  And are
metafilter.com, dailykos.com, and livejournal.com all spammers now?

-- Keith C. Ivey <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Washington, DC



Add tinyurl.com and pastebin.com to that list.
Perhaps - instead of considering a hostname that has wildcards as being spam,
would it be possible to resolve each hostname piecemeal, starting with "b.a"
and then if there is a third portion, "c.b.a", and so on. When a host resolves
to an IP that exists in an RBL, then its spam.   If we hit a wildcard, then
stop, so if "*.b.a" exists, then look up the IP for that record in the RBL, but
go no further.

This should be enough to protect privacy since encoded URLs in the host portion
of a domain won't be looked up, but we'll still get the IP to check.

-- Evan

Reply via email to