http://issues.apache.org/SpamAssassin/show_bug.cgi?id=5662





------- Additional Comments From [EMAIL PROTECTED]  2007-09-28 13:13 -------
-1 on something like r580453 for 3.2.4.

The change unnecessarily removes functionality, removes useful debugging info,
changes the behaviour of existing configs, has overly verbose (and thus
confusing) documentation, uses a number or real domains in examples (and those
domains don't even support DKIM), references SSP which is still in limbo (I
intentionally omitted it with the intention to reference it once everything was
settled with it) and possibly hides something I've missed in the massive change
of $scanner to $scan all over the place.

My biggest issue is with only allowing for an exact match of the provided
optional signing identity.  At the very least you need to allow for sub domain
globing.  Additionally, when an optional signing identity is provided there
shouldn't be any fallback to using the originator identity.

BTW, there was no misinterpretation (at least on my part) of what an identity
is, merely simplification.  Anyone familiar with DKIM would be fine with (ie.
understand) the docs how they were, and anyone not very familiar with DKIM need
not be confused by an overly detailed explanation.  You must remember that a
large portion of our user base is comprised of shrink wrap admins who are often
clueless of all things network related, such as DKIM.  I'm sure you'll find that
the average SA user is far less technically adept than the average amavisd-new 
user.



------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are the assignee for the bug, or are watching the assignee.

Reply via email to