Thanks Suresh for the feedback. Please find comments in-line: On Wed, Apr 30, 2014 at 1:56 PM, Suresh Marru <sma...@apache.org> wrote:
> -1 on the release. > > There are no incubator disclaimers in the artifacts. > > Hi Imesh, > > * Its too soon for you to take this vote to the general list, with a fleet > of IPMC members on this PPMC, it will be a shame to go ask for help on > general with 0 IPMC votes on this list. > > Thanks for pointing out. > * Releases are not customary to keep for 72 hours, for the size of this > PPMC I expect lot more vigilant participation in release verifications. > * I see some discussion of functional testing but no verification of any > license and notice files. For instance the > apache-stratos-cli-4.0.0-incubating LICENSE file lists whole bunch of > licenses and all I see is one jar in this package. > Yes what you have noticed is correct. The reason for this is that apache-stratos-cli-4.0.0-incubating (CLI) has packaged all dependent jar files into one jar file. Do you think we need to change this model? > > * Incubator disclaimer is mandatory in all artifacts. > Yes we will fix this. > > * Before I spend any more time, did the PPMC dig up previous release > discussions and guidance and verify all of them are addressed for this > release as well? > Yes we actually did but we have missed the DISCLAIMER files.
