To my recollection we haven't released with a bug that made me think about
immediately re-releasing a patch since 2011, but it looks like 3.4.5 has
something not so nice in it. It was brought to light on gremlin-users today
and I created this JIRA for it:

https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TINKERPOP-2338

While the bug has a workaround it's not nice and existing Gremlin matching
that pattern will immediately stop behaving properly on upgrade. Given that
the bug is related to graph mutations I find that a bit high on the
worrisome scale.

I suppose the good news is that we learned about the problem quickly before
a ton of new code went to 3.4-dev and there is a fix that is surgical and
touches very little code. So, we could reasonably get this change through
review, merge it to 3.4-dev, create 3.4.6 artifacts and prepare for VOTE. I
don't see the need for a week long code freeze - we just skip to release
VOTE.

So, I suppose the points for discussion here are:

1. Is the bug bad enough to warrant an immediate release of 3.4.6 (note
3.3.11 is unaffected)?
2. If so, are we good with a quick review/merge and an immediate build of a
3.4.6 artifact for VOTE or should we perhaps take a bit more time to see if
other bad news comes in?

Reply via email to