пн, 15 июн. 2026 г. в 12:02, Rainer Jung <[email protected]>: > > Picking up the date suggested by Mark I propose to announce the EOL date > 2027-06-30 for the worker types ajp12 and ajp14 in Tomcat connectors aka > mod_jk aka ISAPI redirector. > > Reason for ajp12: The sources say it is deprecated at least for a decade > now, the docs say it's obsolete. I never saw it in use or remember any > question raised about it. > > Reason for ajp14: it was always experimental. I never saw it in use or > remember any question raised about it. > > Some source code files or types and functions could be dropped as well > at the EOL date, because they are only used by ajp12 or ajp14 (eg. > jk_sockbuf annd jk_sb_* for ajp12, jk_md5 for ajp14). > > Setting EOL date for ajp12: > > [ ] Yes, I agree with EOL 2027-06-30 > [ ] No, I don't agree with any EOL > [x] I strongly prefer EOL date .......... instead > > Setting EOL date for ajp14: > > [ ] Yes, I agree with EOL 2027-06-30 > [ ] No, I don't agree with any EOL > [x] I strongly prefer EOL date .......... instead
My strong preference is for NOW as the EOL date. Where are those protocols documented? At the specifications page in the wiki I have only a link to v 1.3. https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/TOMCAT/Specifications#Specifications-AJP No clue about v1.2. Is 1.4 covered by https://tomcat.apache.org/connectors-doc/ajp/ajpv13ext.html What other side of a server-server connection implements these protocols? I think that Tomcat does not implement them. Are they disabled by default? If we have no clue and cannot really provide technical support, it would be fair to declare it publicly. If not now, an alternative may be to put our EOL message into the release announcement, and delete the code with the next release (that might be a month or a year away), but I see no real benefit for the delay. Best regards, Konstantin Kolinko --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
