Hi Rashmi comments in-line...
On Fri, Nov 11, 2011 at 12:03 AM, Rashmi Hunt <rashmih...@gmail.com> wrote: > I like to understand in oasis, why user can not specify both wsdlElement > and uri for binding.ws? > > For e.g to support SOAP over JMS, the reference binding could be defined as > > <reference name="accountServiceTopic"> > <interface.wsdl > interface="http://www.mybank.com/account#wsdl.interface(AccountServiceTopic)"/> > <binding.ws > wsdlElement="http://www.mybank.com/account#wsdl.port(AccountServiceTopic/AccountServiceTopic)" > uri="jms:jndi:jms/MyBankTopic_Request?jndiConnectionFactoryName=jms/MyBankTopic_CF&targetService=AccountServiceTopic/AccountServiceTopic"/> > </reference> > > This reference fails in WebServiceBindingProcessor class since the code > checks for validation > rule BWS20019 from WebService Binding spec. The exception is > > "[BWS20019] with binding.ws you can only specify one of url, > wsa:EndpointReference, #wsdl.service or #wsdl.port. > The following were found [uri, #wsdl.port]" > > at line > > error(monitor, "MultipleEndpointsSpecified", reader, > endpointSpecifications.toString() ); As you say. This is an explicit rule in the spec. > > I looked through WS Binding spec, specifically section 2.2 and there is no > mention of > SOAP over JMS uri and wsdlElement. > > Industry standard JMS uri for SOAP over JMS follows this pattern > jms:jndi:<destination-jndi-name>?<property>=<value>&<property>=<value>&... > > I tried removing wsdlElement attribute in above example and with just "uri" > defined, to avoid BWS20019 validation error, > I hit different validation exception in Tuscany, which is ASM60033 > > [ASM60033] No targets for reference: Composite = > {http://docs.oasis-open.org/ns/opencsa/sca/200912} Reference = > accountService > > Any pointers? There seems to be something odd about the rest case as this is reporting and error on reference "accountService" while the above SCDl only includes configuration for reference "accountServiceTopic" > > Regards > Rashmi Simon -- Apache Tuscany committer: tuscany.apache.org Co-author of a book about Tuscany and SCA: tuscanyinaction.com
