I'm cancelling rc5, to change 3 lines in the uimaj-examples classpath file - so these reference the correct versions of 3 jars needed for running the v3 migration tool.
Those will be the only changes, in order to make re-checking the release for voting quicker and easier. -Marshall On 10/21/2017 4:25 PM, Richard Eckart de Castilho wrote: > On 17.10.2017, at 17:40, Marshall Schor <[email protected]> wrote: >> Please vote on release: >> >> [ ] +1 OK to release >> [ ] 0 Don't care >> [ ] -1 Not OK to release, because ... > > - checked for differences between SVN tag and sources ZIP: OK > - build with Java 8 and empty Maven repo: OK > - built uimaFIT v3-branch against beta: OK > - built DKPro Core v3-branch against beta: OK > - RELEASE_NOTES file: OK > - sometimes it is "Beta", sometimes "beta" > - mailing list URL is not a link > - Trying to install plugins into Eclipse (from update site): OK > - However, Eclipse says that the JARs are unsigned! (features + plugins) > - Importing the example project into Eclipse: FAIL > - The project imports ok, but some libraries in the project > have older versions than what is actually provided in the lib folder > - Signature spot check: OK > > Well, all in all, it's probably good enough for a beta version > which likely targets existing users rather than new users. But > e.g. the example project should be fixed for the final release. > > [X] +1 OK to release > > General notes: > - IMHO beta releases should be numbered (-beta-1, -beta-2, etc.) > - The "Overview and Setup" document contains a section on > changes from previous major versions. Would be nice to have > such a section for UIMA 3. There is also a section for > "the migration utility" (from IBM UIMA to Apache UIMA). > This could be updated with info about the new utility > for v2 to v3 migration. > - The V3 users guide looks very useful, but I need more time > to read it properly. > - The getting-started guide still talks about fetching UIMA > from our old incubator website and that the Eclipse plugins > require Java 1.5. > > Cheers, > > -- Richard > >
