On Tue, 25 Apr 2023 at 01:08, Craig Russell <apache....@gmail.com> wrote: > > I did a bad job at designing the update to the whimsy/roster tool to add new > PMC member. > > When I got to actually looking at the User Interface, I was surprised to see > that the process is not fit for purpose and would need to be redesigned. > > What I found was that the tool is organized to be able to process multiple > committers at a time, or multiple PMC members at a time. Not only have I > never seen multiple actions occur, but the pop-up doesn't allow for multiple > links to VOTEs. So we need another pop-up with just one name on it. > > And, it was pretty tough to figure out, just looking at the PMC list with all > the PMC members followed by all the committers, that the idea is to tick the > box next to the committer and go back to the top of the screen to (ADD) > (MODIFY). > > So my design decision is to add a box to the committer line which will bring > up the pop-up with the link to lists.apache.org and votelink.
Remember that people can be added to the PMC without being promoted from committer. e.g. the person is already a committer elsewhere, or the PMC treats has committers === PMC. It might be better to just disable PMC promotion if more than one person is selected. > I'll still need help with the details but I'm going to start over with the > implementation. > > Thanks, > Craig > > Craig L Russell > c...@apache.org >
