pe 14. heinäk. 2023 klo 10.29 Rob Audenaerde (rob.audenae...@gmail.com) kirjoitti:
> Are you looking for something like this? > > > https://www.jetbrains.com/help/idea/work-with-github-pull-requests.html#provide-feedback > > As far as I know, there is no universal standard for code-review-feedback > that works in all IDEs, that would be very nice :) > Thanks, yes, a standard for code-review-feedback that works in all IDEs would be very nice 😄 I'm looking for something more like this: https://agilereview.org/ I added feature request: https://github.com/AgileReview-Project/AgileReview-EclipsePlugin/issues/6 - store review comments within the same project & repository as the code itself - commit the comments into the same project & repository as the code itself - ability to compare changes in comments overall or within comments, between code/comment commit versions (similar to code compare changes where you would see the changed files, changed comments within, changes/additions to comments in compare changes style) - abiliy to add/edit comments in both code comparison mode and normal coding mode to better support the code review process - think user experience similar to "Add comment" feature in Google Docs Feel free to upvote if there is such possibility 😉 They already have some plugins so in theory this could be evolved into an universal standard: https://github.com/AgileReview-Project ** Martin > On Fri, Jul 14, 2023 at 8:49 AM Martin Terra < > martin.te...@koodaripalvelut.com> wrote: > > > Sorry for being bit off topic here, but I'm looking for a software tool > or > > plugin suitable for Java programming that allows developers to > > insert/manage review comments directly from within their IDE, similar to > > the "Add comment" feature in Google Docs. > > > > I belive it would benefit the Wicket Community as well, if such tool > could > > be integrated with the code repository. > > > > Do you have experience of such tool? In my understanding, for example > > github review comments cannot be collaborated with directly from within > the > > IDE, or is there a plugin for that? Furthermore, preferably it would work > > directly with native git without requiring the use of the github > platform. > > > > This functionality would be valuable for code review discussion which is > > often closely tied to specific sections of the code, making it easier for > > others to understand the context, intent, and purpose of the comments > > relative to the code context. It would be particularly beneficial if this > > tool could also be used in the ”compare different versions” mode of the > IDE > > which is typically used when reviewing code, enabling reviewers to > provide > > feedback on specific changes made between versions. > > > > Additionally, it would be advantageous if these review comments could be > > stored in the code repository in a manner that allows viewers to see a > > comprehensive view of comments from all reviewers. This unified view, > > similar to the commenting feature in Google Docs, would provide a better > > understanding of the feedback and suggestions offered by multiple > > reviewers, ensuring that all perspectives are considered and facilitating > > effective communication and collaboration among team members. > > > > By integrating review comments directly within the code, the code review > > process would be significantly enhanced. It would reduce friction in the > > process of giving, understanding, tracking, and managing comments, > > resulting in improved collaboration on the project. Other future benefits > > could be in training AI models based on history of commits and reviews. > > > > > > ** > > Martin > > >
