Hi, Well I also did a quick comparison of the Appserver product and service, plugins dir and noticed that there some jar only used in the product pack and vise-versa. In another thread we agreed that we could accept the final product distro growing about 5 MB, due the service specific jars (throttling, sso etc.). However I am not quite sure why there are some jars only used in the product (see attached diff file), I was under the impression that; service = product + stratos features.
Apart from the bundles, there is also config files as Senaka mentioned that needs to be handled. So I think we need to define a strategy on we are going to merge the 2 distros. I agree that that its not going to be straight forward, but it is going to be very helpful. Since the platform and products are only getting more and more complex, I feel the sooner we start working on merging the two, the better. Thoughts? On Thu, Mar 22, 2012 at 10:49 PM, Senaka Fernando <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi Azeez, > > I had a look. Merging the some Services and Products is going to be > challenging. For example, let's take Governance. The service has several > things that is not required in the product. To start with there are two > registry.xml files. Also, there are multiple features in the Service > P2-profile that should not be available with the product. Ex:- throttling > agent, metering, SSO bundles etc. Unless we sort out how to scrap these > when building the product, this is not going to easily work. The same is > also applicable to the product, where there are some client libraries that > is not part of the service. > > Also, what I don't like is to introduce hacks to check whether it is > product-mode or service-mode and do selective branching, which duplicates > and makes code really ugly and unorganized. So, unless we find a better way > to sort issues like these out, its best kept separate right now. > > I also do accept the fact that this might not be the case for some other > products. > > Thanks, > Senaka. > > On Thu, Mar 22, 2012 at 8:05 PM, Afkham Azeez <[email protected]> wrote: > >> Have the respective product teams started looking into this? >> >> -- >> *Afkham Azeez* >> Director of Architecture; WSO2, Inc.; http://wso2.com >> Member; Apache Software Foundation; http://www.apache.org/ >> * <http://www.apache.org/>** >> email: **[email protected]* <[email protected]>* cell: +94 77 3320919 >> blog: **http://blog.afkham.org* <http://blog.afkham.org>* >> twitter: **http://twitter.com/afkham_azeez*<http://twitter.com/afkham_azeez> >> * >> linked-in: **http://lk.linkedin.com/in/afkhamazeez* >> * >> * >> *Lean . Enterprise . Middleware* >> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Dev mailing list >> [email protected] >> http://wso2.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/dev >> >> > > > -- > *Senaka Fernando* > Product Manager - WSO2 Governance Registry; > Associate Technical Lead; WSO2 Inc.; http://wso2.com* > Member; Apache Software Foundation; http://apache.org > > E-mail: senaka AT wso2.com > **P: +1 408 754 7388; ext: 51736*; *M: +94 77 322 1818 > Linked-In: http://linkedin.com/in/senakafernando > > * > Lean . Enterprise . Middleware > > > _______________________________________________ > Dev mailing list > [email protected] > http://wso2.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/dev > > -- Thanks, Shariq. Phone: +94 777 202 225
shariq@shariq-laptop:~/src/trunk/platform/products/as$ diff modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/ modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/ Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: antlr_2.7.7.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: apache-zookeeper_3.3.4.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: arq_1.0.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: bsh_1.3.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: cassandra-jdbc_1.0.5.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: commons-pool_1.5.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: gdata-core_1.0.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: gdata-spreadsheet_3.0.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: google-collect_1.0.0.wso2v2.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: htmlcleaner_2.1.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: ooxml-spreadsheet-schemas_1.1.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.appserver.styles_4.5.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.coordination.common_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.coordination.core_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.dataservices.common_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.dataservices.core_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.dataservices.fileupload.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.dataservices.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.dataservices.ui_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.datasource_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.datasource.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.datasource.ui_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.deployment.synchronizer.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.deployment.synchronizer.ui_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.mashup.javascript-scraper_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.mashup.javascript-scraper.ui_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.ntask.common_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.ntask.core_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.ntask.solutions_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: quartz_2.1.1.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: saxon_8.9.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/product/target/wso2as-4.5.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: synapse-commons_2.1.0.wso2v6.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: antlr_3.2.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: atlassian-jira_1.0.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: axis_1.4.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: jaxb_2.1.6.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: jdom_1.0.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: openid4java-nodeps_0.9.6.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: guava_11.0.1.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: guice_3.0.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.account.mgt.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.activation_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.announcement_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.bam.data.publisher.servicestats_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.bam.data.publisher.servicestats.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.bam.data.publisher.servicestats.ui_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.bam.lwevent.core_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.discovery.admin.ui_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.discovery.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.event.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.event.ui_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.gapp.registration.ui_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.google.analytics.ui_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.authenticator.saml2.sso_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.authenticator.saml2.sso.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.authenticator.saml2.sso.ui_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.base_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.core_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.menu.ui_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.provider_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.provider.openid_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.provider.openid.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.provider.openid.ui_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.relyingparty_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.relyingparty.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.identity.relyingparty.ui_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.issue.tracker.adapter_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.issue.tracker.core_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.issue.tracker.mgt_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.issue.tracker.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.issue.tracker.ui_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.jira.reporting_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.load.balance.agent_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.redirector.servlet_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.redirector.servlet.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.redirector.servlet.ui_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.sample.installer_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.sso.redirector.ui_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.stratos.common_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.stratos.common.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.stratos.deployment_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.stratos.landing.page.deployer_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.task_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.tenant.activity_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.tenant.dispatcher_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.tenant.reg.agent.service_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.tenant.register.gapp.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.throttling.agent_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.throttling.agent.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.tomcat.patch_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.ui.menu.stratos_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.um.ws.api.stub_4.0.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.carbon.usage.agent_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.stratos.appserver.dashboard.ui_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.stratos.appserver.login.ui_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.stratos.appserver.sample.installer.ui_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: org.wso2.stratos.appserver.styles_1.1.0.SNAPSHOT.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: quartz_1.6.0.wso2v2.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: smack_3.0.4.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: step2_1.0.0.wso2v1.jar Only in modules/distribution/service/target/wso2stratos-as-1.1.0-SNAPSHOT/repository/components/plugins/: synapse-tasks_2.1.0.wso2v6.jar
_______________________________________________ Dev mailing list [email protected] http://wso2.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/dev
