XFireFault is not serialized correctly when it is a descendant of a child
element of SOAP Body
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Key: XFIRE-990
URL: http://jira.codehaus.org/browse/XFIRE-990
Project: XFire
Issue Type: Bug
Environment: 1.2.5
Reporter: Reshat Sabiq
Assignee: Dan Diephouse
SOAP 1.2 says: "A SOAP Fault element information item MAY appear within a SOAP
header block, or as a descendant of a child element information item of the
SOAP Body ; in such cases, the element has no SOAP-defined semantics."
Given that the spec allows it, i think xfire should handle.
Given that we have regular faults, and we don't completely stop processing
after an exception pertaining to an individual subrequest, i'm trying to
indicate the status of an individual subrequest using a soap:Fault as well.
However, when representing that fault w/ XFireFault, it is not serialized as a
soap:Fault, e.g. shown below. It is instead serialized like a regular java
object.
One thought i have is to represent this as a String field, and serialize it
manually into soap:Fault, so that client can peruse individual status codes
similarly to complete failures indicated by soap:Fault (this would involve JAXB
and such outside of xfire, because we are not using java 5, and can't do
schema-to-java). Another way could involve a handler, and replacing content in
OutMessage. But first is not declarative, and 2nd would be a potential
performance drag. I think this should be handled by the framework itself.
P.S. This is what i was hoping for as a field of a subrequest:
<soap:Fault>
<soap:Code>
<soap:Value>soap:Sender</soap:Value>
<soap:SubCode>
<soap:Value
xmlns:error="urn:some.urn">error:SomeError</soap:Value>
</soap:SubCode>
</soap:Code>
<soap:Reason>
<soap:Text>Some Error</soap:Text>
</soap:Reason>
<soap:Detail>
<error:detail code="1001"
xmlns:error="urn:some.urn">someField</error:detail>
</soap:Detail>
</soap:Fault>
P.P.S. This is what is serialized by xfire as of now:
<fault>
<detail xmlns="http://fault.xfire.codehaus.org";>
<soap:Detail>
<error:detail code="1001"
xmlns:error="urn:some.urn"/>
</soap:Detail>
</detail>
<faultCode xmlns="http://fault.xfire.codehaus.org";>
<localPart
xmlns="http://namespace.xml.javax";>Sender</localPart>
<namespaceURI
xmlns="http://namespace.xml.javax";>http://www.w3.org/2003/05/soap-envelope</namespaceURI>
<prefix xmlns="http://namespace.xml.javax"/>
</faultCode>
<message xmlns="http://fault.xfire.codehaus.org";>Some
Error</message>
<namespaces xmlns="http://fault.xfire.codehaus.org"/>
<reason xmlns="http://fault.xfire.codehaus.org";>Some
Error</reason>
<role xsi:nil="true"
xmlns="http://fault.xfire.codehaus.org"/>
<subCode xmlns="http://fault.xfire.codehaus.org";>
<localPart
xmlns="http://namespace.xml.javax";>SomeError</localPart>
<namespaceURI
xmlns="http://namespace.xml.javax";>urn:some.urn</namespaceURI>
<prefix
xmlns="http://namespace.xml.javax";>error</prefix>
</subCode>
</fault>
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
-
If you think it was sent incorrectly contact one of the administrators:
http://jira.codehaus.org/secure/Administrators.jspa
-
For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from this list please visit:
http://xircles.codehaus.org/manage_email
