On Nov 12, 2010, at 10:18:11, Robert Vehse wrote: > > As suggested by David Munch (Thain) I regularly asked for feedback from Adium > users on a forum thread.[3] This is the current revision of Bogdan's: > http://forums.cocoaforge.com/viewtopic.php?f=13&t=22217&start=20#p127356. I > think it is really good!
Chat window toolbar: All look good to me. I do prefer the chain-link version of the Add/Edit Link icon. Preferences window toolbar: I prefer our current icons, with exceptions: - Status: I could go either way. I prefer most of our current icons because they're Adiumy-themed, not generic icons. However, the DND door sign probably is clearer than a wooden sign with a clock on it. - File Transfer: I prefer Bogdan's icon. - Advanced: You could make a case that our current icon, with its “e=mc²” joke, scares people off from this pane. The plain gear might work better, even as non-descriptive as it is. (Especially consider that most of the preferences within that pane are not really that advanced, just niche and/or service-specific.) Event action icons: Most of these are good, with exceptions: - Script: I prefer our current icon. - Speak: I think we need a new icon, but a bollard isn't it. A microphone doesn't make sense here, since it's output, not input. Might I suggest a pair of lips?
