I am working on sorting out a failure on test 605 of the SBSA test. The test is "Where a memory access is to an unpopulated part of the addressable memory space, accesses must be terminated in a manner that is presented to the PE as either a precise Data Abort or that causes a system error interrupt or an SPI or LPI interrupt to be delivered to the GIC." The issue is that the random test address that was chosen 0x04200000 falls directly in the middle of the Qoriq configuration, control, and status register (CCSR) address space. This is an area in the memory space that provides CPU access to the device registers.
An entry is added for this region in the VirtualMemoryMap, and registered with the attribute, ARM_MEMORY_REGION_ATTRIBUTE_DEVICE. However only a handful of devices are being registered so only a couple of ranges are showing up in memmap as MMIO. The SBSA test in question gets the memorymap and starts at the address mentioned above and looks for the first chunk of memory that is free and then attempts to access the memory and is looking for a Data Abort. Of course a data abort is not generated because 0x04200000 is a valid address. If you offset this to 0x42000000 then a DA is generated as expected and the test passes. There is a very old thread started by Ard, "MMIO regions in GetMemoryMap ()", in which he questions if all the MMIO regions should be reported by GetMemoryMap() or only the ones being used by initialized devices, which is what the current implementation does. The end result of the thread was the current implementation is correct. That leaves me with the question, "What is the proper solution for the current implementation that I am working with?" To me it seems like I need a special Library that on boot goes through and claims and maps every valid MMIO slot in this region, and then have the drivers use this library for proxying requests to gDS->AddMemorySpace (), gDS->SetMemorySpaceAttributes () etc. If there is a standardized way to deal with this configuration I would much rather follow that. Thanks for any input, Jon -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Groups.io Links: You receive all messages sent to this group. View/Reply Online (#49748): https://edk2.groups.io/g/devel/message/49748 Mute This Topic: https://groups.io/mt/40108740/21656 Group Owner: [email protected] Unsubscribe: https://edk2.groups.io/g/devel/unsub [[email protected]] -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
