SHORT VERSION
=============
Our nightly snapshot tarball filenames have become confusing. Here's the most
recent on each branch:
- Master: openmpi-v2.x-dev-3019-gbd1b6fe.tar.bz2
- v2.0.x: openmpi-v2.0.1-93-g97511a1.tar.bz2
- v2.x: openmpi-v2.0.1-203-g56991c6.tar.bz2
I propose changing them to the following format:
openmpi-${BRANCHNAME}-${YYYYMMDD}-${SHORTHASH}.tar.bz2
Here's what last night's tarballs would have looked like with that scheme:
openmpi-master-20161017-bd1b6fe.tar.bz2
openmpi-v2.0.x-20161017-a66f3e2.tar.bz2
openmpi-v2.x-20161017-56991c6.tar.bz2
Optionally, we could put a HHMM timestamp in there for finer granularity.
MORE DETAIL
===========
We use "git describe" to come up with the version strings for our nightly
snapshot tarballs. "git describe" shows you three things:
- the first tag that it finds going back along the git commit history
- the number of commits it had to traverse to find that tag
- the short hast of the HEAD commit
For lack of a longer explanation, the names of the current snapshots *do* make
sense given our commit and tag history; they're just... weird.
After talking this through with a colleague today, I think we have two choices:
1. Continue to use the "git describe" output
2. Come up with a different scheme
Using git describe output means that we are reliant on git tags. Funky
placement of git tags -- including the moving of branches back from
ompi-release to ompi -- is how we ended up in this situation. This might
constitute empirical evidence that "git describe" is not a good solution for
this community.
Instead, perhaps we should make a new scheme. We need two properties in the
snapshot filenames:
1. Name of the branch that the tarball came from.
2. Easily sortable by a human (i.e., know that tarball X came before or after
tarball Y).
Property #1 is self-evident (the branch name is in the filename); property #2
comes from the timestamp.
NOTE: It may be desirable to add HHMM in there; it's not common, but
*sometimes* we do make more than one snapshot in a day (e.g., if one snapshot
is borked, so we fix it and then generate another snapshot).
--
Jeff Squyres
jsquy...@cisco.com
For corporate legal information go to:
http://www.cisco.com/web/about/doing_business/legal/cri/
_______________________________________________
devel mailing list
devel@lists.open-mpi.org
https://rfd.newmexicoconsortium.org/mailman/listinfo/devel
