Removing mmadmin and mmexample is fine with us. But given the current status of the JSP editors I would be against removing the SCAN editors. (At this stage I would even advise new MMBase users to use the SCAN editors instead of the JSP-ones!) I believe that serious effort should be made to make the JSP editors a functional equivalent of the SCAN editors. Only then removing the SCAN editors is an option. We’ve got a large community of users that are familiar with the behaviour of the SCAN editors. Currently the JSP editors are not an acceptable alternative. Maybe removing de editors is fine from a developers perspective, but from the perspective of a user with a large community of end-users, giving them a good alternative to what you want to remove is the only wise option.

Gr, RJ

Kees Jongenburger heeft op dinsdag, 1 apr 2003 om 18:37 (Europe/Amsterdam) het volgende geschreven:

I don't think this is a real option
The hole goal is to get the CVS as clean as possible

we are talking about 356 .shtml files
206 from the mmedidors
57 from the mmadmin interface
93 from the mmexample

I think
-the mmadmin can be removed since there is a good alternative
-the mmexamples can be removed a I hope nobody wil start using scan

we shouid keep the scan editor for the moment since the taglib ones don't
provider a good alternative (yet?). maybe the best thing to do is just to put
them in a zip file. put it on the site somewhere?




Reply via email to