development
Thread
Date
Earlier messages
Later messages
Messages by Date
2025/01/22
[Development] [Announce] Qt 6.9.0 Beta2 released
List for announcements regarding Qt releases and development via Announce via Development
2025/01/22
[Development] [Announce] Security advisory: A read past the end of the buffer and division by zero security issue in QLowEnergyController on Linux impacts Qt
List for announcements regarding Qt releases and development via Announce via Development
2025/01/22
Re: [Development] Nominating Tero Heikkinen as an approver for the Qt Project
Matti Paaso via Development
2025/01/22
Re: [Development] Nominating Ville-Pekka Karhu as an approver for the Qt Project
Matti Paaso via Development
2025/01/22
Re: [Development] Nominating Tero Heikkinen as an approver for the Qt Project
Liang Qi via Development
2025/01/22
Re: [Development] Nominating Tero Heikkinen as an approver for the Qt Project
Tony Sarajärvi via Development
2025/01/22
Re: [Development] Nominating Ville-Pekka Karhu as an approver for the Qt Project
Tony Sarajärvi via Development
2025/01/22
Re: [Development] Nominating Ville-Pekka Karhu as an approver for the Qt Project
Simo Fält via Development
2025/01/22
Re: [Development] Nominating Tero Heikkinen as an approver for the Qt Project
Simo Fält via Development
2025/01/21
[Development] Meeting minutes from Qt Release Team meeting 21.01.2025
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2025/01/20
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Thiago Macieira
2025/01/20
[Development] [Announce] Qt Safe Renderer 2.1 Released
List for announcements regarding Qt releases and development via Announce via Development
2025/01/20
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Allan Sandfeld Jensen
2025/01/20
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Sune Vuorela
2025/01/20
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Schimkowitsch Robert
2025/01/20
Re: [Development] Nominating Tero Heikkinen as an approver for the Qt Project
Paul Wicking via Development
2025/01/20
[Development] Nominating Tero Heikkinen as an approver for the Qt Project
Jukka Jokiniva via Development
2025/01/20
[Development] Nominating Ville-Pekka Karhu as an approver for the Qt Project
Jukka Jokiniva via Development
2025/01/20
Re: [Development] HEADS-UP: Branching from '6.8' to '6.8.2' done
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2025/01/19
[Development] HEADS-UP: Branching from '6.8' to '6.8.2' done
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2025/01/17
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Thiago Macieira
2025/01/17
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Marco Bubke via Development
2025/01/17
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Marc Mutz via Development
2025/01/17
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Allan Sandfeld Jensen
2025/01/17
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Allan Sandfeld Jensen
2025/01/16
[Development] [Announce] Qt 6.2.11 Opensource released
List for announcements regarding Qt releases and development via Announce via Development
2025/01/16
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Thiago Macieira
2025/01/16
Re: [Development] API style guide: scoped enum or not?
Marc Mutz via Development
2025/01/16
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Mathias Hasselmann via Development
2025/01/16
Re: [Development] API style guide: scoped enum or not?
Thiago Macieira
2025/01/16
Re: [Development] API style guide: scoped enum or not?
Marc Mutz via Development
2025/01/16
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Marc Mutz via Development
2025/01/16
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2025/01/16
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Marc Mutz via Development
2025/01/16
Re: [Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Tor Arne Vestbø via Development
2025/01/16
[Development] Qt 6.9.0 3rd party component update
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2025/01/16
[Development] Proposing to change https://wiki.qt.io/API_Design_Principles#Enums_in_classes to require scoped enums
Marc Mutz via Development
2025/01/16
Re: [Development] HEADS-UP: Qt 6.9 API change review
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2025/01/15
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Schimkowitsch Robert
2025/01/15
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Edward Welbourne via Development
2025/01/15
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Marc Mutz via Development
2025/01/15
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Jyrki Yli-Nokari
2025/01/15
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Schimkowitsch Robert
2025/01/14
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
apoenitz
2025/01/14
[Development] Meeting minutes from Qt Release Team meeting 14.01.2025
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2025/01/14
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Thiago Macieira
2025/01/14
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Thiago Macieira
2025/01/14
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Philippe
2025/01/14
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Marc Mutz via Development
2025/01/14
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Thiago Macieira
2025/01/14
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Jaroslaw Kobus via Development
2025/01/14
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Ville Voutilainen
2025/01/14
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2025/01/14
Re: [Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Ivan Solovev via Development
2025/01/13
[Development] QtCS 2024 session on deprecations: what did we actually agree on?
Marc Mutz via Development
2025/01/10
[Development] [Announce] Qt 6.5.4 Opensource released
List for announcements regarding Qt releases and development via Announce via Development
2025/01/07
[Development] Meeting minutes from Qt Release Team meeting 07.01.2025
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2025/01/07
Re: [Development] Monthly CI maintenance break - January (Tue, Jan 7th 2025)
CI Maintenance Break via Development
2025/01/06
Re: [Development] Monthly CI maintenance break - January (Tue, Jan 7th 2025)
CI Maintenance Break via Development
2025/01/06
Re: [Development] Nominating Bartlomiej Moskal as an approver for the Qt project
Alex Blasche via Development
2025/01/06
Re: [Development] Nominating Wladimir Leuschner as an approver for the Qt project
Alex Blasche via Development
2025/01/02
Re: [Development] Shaders in QRhi
Paul Tvete via Development
2025/01/02
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Matthias Rauter via Development
2024/12/31
[Development] Monthly CI maintenance break - January (Tue, Jan 7th 2025)
CI Maintenance Break via Development
2024/12/30
Re: [Development] Adding QUIP24 - Blacklisting flaky tests
Ville Voutilainen
2024/12/27
[Development] Adding QUIP24 - Blacklisting flaky tests
Axel Spoerl via Development
2024/12/22
Re: [Development] Nominating Bartlomiej Moskal as an approver for the Qt project
Rami Potinkara via Development
2024/12/22
Re: [Development] Shaders in QRhi
Harald Vistnes
2024/12/21
Re: [Development] Shaders in QRhi
Giuseppe D'Angelo via Development
2024/12/21
[Development] Shaders in QRhi
Harald Vistnes
2024/12/20
Re: [Development] QUIP-18 and file "reclassification"
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2024/12/20
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2024/12/19
Re: [Development] QUIP-18 and file "reclassification"
Jörg Bornemann via Development
2024/12/19
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2024/12/19
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Oliver Eftevaag via Development
2024/12/19
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2024/12/19
[Development] QUIP-18 and file "reclassification"
Marc Mutz via Development
2024/12/18
Re: [Development] Nominating Ali Kianian as an approver for the Qt Project
Alex Blasche via Development
2024/12/18
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Alex Blasche via Development
2024/12/18
[Development] Meeting minutes from Qt Release Team meeting 17.12.2024
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2024/12/17
Re: [Development] Changed Branding on doc-snapshots.qt.io
Paul Wicking via Development
2024/12/17
[Development] [Announce] Qt 6.9 Beta1 Released
List for announcements regarding Qt releases and development via Announce via Development
2024/12/17
Re: [Development] Nominating Bartlomiej Moskal as an approver for the Qt project
Timur Pocheptsov via Development
2024/12/16
Re: [Development] Nominating Bartlomiej Moskal as an approver for the Qt project
Jøger Hansegård via Development
2024/12/16
Re: [Development] Changed Branding on doc-snapshots.qt.io
Paul Wicking via Development
2024/12/16
Re: [Development] Changed Branding on doc-snapshots.qt.io
David Redondo
2024/12/16
Re: [Development] Changed Branding on doc-snapshots.qt.io
Kai Köhne via Development
2024/12/16
Re: [Development] Changed Branding on doc-snapshots.qt.io
Paul Wicking via Development
2024/12/16
[Development] Nominating Bartlomiej Moskal as an approver for the Qt project
Assam Boudjelthia via Development
2024/12/16
[Development] Changed Branding on doc-snapshots.qt.io
David Redondo
2024/12/15
Re: [Development] WhatsNew in Qt 6.9
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2024/12/14
Re: [Development] When will wasm platform support Charts or Graphs
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2024/12/13
[Development] When will wasm platform support Charts or Graphs
Glen Mabey
2024/12/13
[Development] [Announce] Qt 6.5.8 LTS Commercial released
List for announcements regarding Qt releases and development via Announce via Development
2024/12/13
Re: [Development] Nominating Wladimir Leuschner as an approver for the Qt project
Tor Arne Vestbø via Development
2024/12/13
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Tor Arne Vestbø via Development
2024/12/13
Re: [Development] Nominating Wladimir Leuschner as an approver for the Qt project
Jøger Hansegård via Development
2024/12/12
Re: [Development] Wasm: Support for Emscripten PROXY_TO_PTHREAD?
Morten Sørvig via Development
2024/12/12
Re: [Development] Wasm: Support for Emscripten JSPI
Morten Sørvig via Development
2024/12/12
Re: [Development] Nominating Ali Kianian as an approver for the Qt Project
Jaroslaw Kobus via Development
2024/12/11
[Development] HEADS-UP: Qt 6.9 API change review
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2024/12/10
[Development] Meeting minutes from Qt Release Team meeting 10.12.2024
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2024/12/10
Re: [Development] HEADS-UP: Branching from 'dev' to '6.9' done & Qt 6.9 Feature Freeze is in effect
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2024/12/10
[Development] Wasm: Support for Emscripten JSPI
Stephan Bergmann
2024/12/10
Re: [Development] Nominating Wladimir Leuschner as an approver for the Qt project
Axel Spoerl via Development
2024/12/10
[Development] Qt 6.9 Feature Freeze Exception: Export symbols in QTestGui namespace
Axel Spoerl via Development
2024/12/10
Re: [Development] Wasm: Support for Emscripten PROXY_TO_PTHREAD?
Stephan Bergmann
2024/12/09
Re: [Development] Nominating Ali Kianian as an approver for the Qt Project
Thomas Hartmann via Development
2024/12/09
Re: [Development] HEADS-UP: Branching from 'dev' to '6.9' done & Qt 6.9 Feature Freeze is in effect
Mitch Curtis via Development
2024/12/09
Re: [Development] HEADS-UP: Branching from 'dev' to '6.9' done & Qt 6.9 Feature Freeze is in effect
Axel Spoerl via Development
2024/12/09
Re: [Development] Problem finding the ToolsDependencies.cmake files - why without search paths?
Alexandru Croitor via Development
2024/12/09
Re: [Development] HEADS-UP: Branching from 'dev' to '6.9' done & Qt 6.9 Feature Freeze is in effect
Tor Arne Vestbø via Development
2024/12/09
[Development] Nominating Wladimir Leuschner as an approver for the Qt project
Oliver Wolff via Development
2024/12/08
[Development] HEADS-UP: Branching from 'dev' to '6.9' done & Qt 6.9 Feature Freeze is in effect
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2024/12/07
Re: [Development] Problem finding the ToolsDependencies.cmake files - why without search paths?
Alexander Neundorf
2024/12/06
Re: [Development] Wasm: Support for Emscripten PROXY_TO_PTHREAD?
Morten Sørvig via Development
2024/12/06
[Development] HEADS-UP: Qt 6.9 Feature Freeze
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2024/12/05
[Development] Problem finding the ToolsDependencies.cmake files - why without search paths?
Alexander Neundorf
2024/12/05
[Development] Wasm: Support for Emscripten PROXY_TO_PTHREAD?
Stephan Bergmann
2024/12/03
[Development] Meeting minutes from Qt Release Team meeting 03.12.2024
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2024/12/03
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Doris Verria via Development
2024/12/03
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Axel Spoerl via Development
2024/12/03
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Eirik Aavitsland via Development
2024/12/03
Re: [Development] Nominating Ali Kianian as an approver for the Qt Project
Miikka Heikkinen via Development
2024/12/03
[Development] Requesting a repository for the Figma Style Generator Tool
Richard Gustavsen via Development
2024/12/03
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Richard Gustavsen via Development
2024/12/03
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Jøger Hansegård via Development
2024/12/03
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Sune Vuorela
2024/12/02
[Development] [Announce] Qt Creator 15 released
List for announcements regarding Qt releases and development via Announce via Development
2024/12/02
[Development] WhatsNew in Qt 6.9 - gerrit change to edit
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2024/12/02
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Alexandru Croitor via Development
2024/12/02
[Development] [Announce] Qt 6.8.1 Released
List for announcements regarding Qt releases and development via Announce via Development
2024/12/02
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Kai Uwe Broulik
2024/12/02
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Ulf Hermann via Development
2024/12/01
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Mitch Curtis via Development
2024/12/01
Re: [Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Jan-Arve Sæther via Development
2024/11/29
[Development] Nominating Oliver Eftevaag as maintainer of Qt Quick Dialogs
Shawn Rutledge via Development
2024/11/29
[Development] Nominating Ali Kianian as an approver for the Qt Project
Mahmoud Ali via Development
2024/11/29
Re: [Development] RFC: Scriptable Widgets
Marcus Tillmanns via Development
2024/11/28
Re: [Development] RFC: Scriptable Widgets
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/28
Re: [Development] RFC: Scriptable Widgets
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2024/11/28
Re: [Development] RFC: Scriptable Widgets
Fabian Kosmale via Development
2024/11/28
Re: [Development] RFC: Scriptable Widgets
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2024/11/28
Re: [Development] RFC: Scriptable Widgets
André Somers via Development
2024/11/28
Re: [Development] RFC: Scriptable Widgets
Marcus Tillmanns via Development
2024/11/28
Re: [Development] RFC: Scriptable Widgets
Marcus Tillmanns via Development
2024/11/28
Re: [Development] RFC: Scriptable Widgets
Shawn Rutledge via Development
2024/11/28
Re: [Development] RFC: Scriptable Widgets
Fabian Kosmale via Development
2024/11/27
[Development] RFC: Scriptable Widgets
Marcus Tillmanns via Development
2024/11/27
Re: [Development] JIra/bugreports update on 28. Nov 2024
Alex Blasche via Development
2024/11/27
Re: [Development] Meeting minutes from Qt Release Team meeting 26.11.2024
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/27
Re: [Development] Switching Qt default builds to C++20 where supported
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/27
Re: [Development] Switching Qt default builds to C++20 where supported
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2024/11/27
[Development] Meeting minutes from Qt Release Team meeting 26.11.2024
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2024/11/26
Re: [Development] Switching Qt default builds to C++20 where supported
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/26
Re: [Development] Switching Qt default builds to C++20 where supported
Tor Arne Vestbø via Development
2024/11/26
Re: [Development] Switching Qt default builds to C++20 where supported
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/26
Re: [Development] Switching Qt default builds to C++20 where supported
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/26
[Development] HEADS-UP: Qt 6.8.1 release note review
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2024/11/25
[Development] HEADS-UP: Qt 6.9 platform and module freeze
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2024/11/25
Re: [Development] Why is QUIP-5 "superseded", and what supersedes it?
Marc Mutz via Development
2024/11/25
Re: [Development] moc output changes coming
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/25
Re: [Development] moc output changes coming
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/25
Re: [Development] moc output changes coming
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2024/11/25
Re: [Development] Why is QUIP-5 "superseded", and what supersedes it?
Arno Rehn
2024/11/25
[Development] Why is QUIP-5 "superseded", and what supersedes it?
Marc Mutz via Development
2024/11/23
Re: [Development] How to relate patch to bug report?
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/22
[Development] How to relate patch to bug report?
Stan Morris
2024/11/21
[Development] JIra/bugreports update on 28. Nov 2024
Alex Blasche via Development
2024/11/20
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/20
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Manuel Bergler
2024/11/20
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/20
[Development] Meeting minutes from Qt Release Team meeting 19.11.2024
Jani Heikkinen via Development
2024/11/20
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Manuel Bergler
2024/11/19
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/19
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/19
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/19
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Alexandru Croitor via Development
2024/11/19
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Alexandru Croitor via Development
2024/11/19
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Alexandru Croitor via Development
2024/11/19
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Alexandru Croitor via Development
2024/11/16
[Development] [Announce] Qt 5.15.16 Opensource released
List for announcements regarding Qt releases and development via Announce via Development
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] Qt Creator 15 RC released
Maija Metso via Development
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] moc output changes coming
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/14
[Development] [Announce] Qt Creator 15 RC released
List for announcements regarding Qt releases and development via Announce via Development
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Sune Vuorela
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Joerg Bornemann via Development
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] moc output changes coming
Ivan Solovev via Development
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Edward Welbourne via Development
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] moc output changes coming
Volker Hilsheimer via Development
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] Deprecated vs deprecated-to-be-removed APIs in Qt
Ivan Solovev via Development
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Tim Blechmann via Development
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Bogdan Vatra via Development
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Sune Vuorela
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] Deprecated vs deprecated-to-be-removed APIs in Qt
Jaroslaw Kobus via Development
2024/11/14
Re: [Development] Deprecated vs deprecated-to-be-removed APIs in Qt
Alex Blasche via Development
2024/11/13
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/13
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Tim Blechmann via Development
2024/11/13
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Thiago Macieira
2024/11/13
Re: [Development] Proposal to raise the minimum CMake version needed to build and use Qt 6.9
Alexandru Croitor via Development
Earlier messages
Later messages