On Thursday, 24 August 2017 at 20:11:32 UTC, data pulverizer wrote:

Thanks. I think most of that is down to D's nice syntax and how it easily and clearly emulates Julia. I think that there is certainly more to say on this especially around strategies of how represent concrete types. David Gileadi's point about UDAs could add an interesting spin on things, and Ali's point on dynamic dispatching.



On UDAs, at least in the current implementation, I think that the actual issue you are trying to address is to force the type in the distribution to be convertible to double in the continuous case and convertible to long in the discrete case. All things considered, that can be implemented with template constraints, as in

class Gamma(T):
    if(isFloatingPoint!T)
{
    immutable(T) shape;
    immutable(T) scale;
    this(T shape, T scale)
    {
        this.shape = shape;
        this.scale = scale;
    }
}

though you could probably take a more abstract approach. (I'm also not 100% on having immutable member variables). Also, density's signature could then avoid the template constraint.

auto density(D: Gamma!T, U : T, T)(D d, U x)

Even better, if you're calling the dstats functions, you could re-write density as something like

auto pdf(D: Dist!T, U : T, Dist, T)(U x, D d) {
mixin("return x." ~ lookupdstatdensity!Dist ~ "(" ~ stringmembersofd ~ ")";
}

and create a lookupdstatdensity function that returns a string of the relevant dstats function at compile-time (and a function returning a string of the members of d) (I also would re-name density to pdf and switch the order of x and d). This would probably be the most DRY approach.

On Ali's point on dynamic dispatching, Julia is a scripting language with a JIT compiler. So if you call a function with some types known at compile time and the overload exists, it will compile the correct version of the function for the relevant types. It will then cache that so that if you need it again you don't pay any additional cost. So it's similar to what you're doing on that respect. However, there is a runtime dispatch component that would take something like openmethods to implement, I think.

Reply via email to