On Wednesday, 23 October 2019 at 04:20:19 UTC, Exil wrote:
it's a bad idea. Why have two community reviews? Those are made with the assumption that the DIP will actually change between the reviews.
No, that's not the assumption. You're conflating Community Review with Final Review. There can be multiple rounds of the former as required and only one of the latter. In a perfect scenario, no revisions are required between CR and FR. The purpose of the Final Review is to provide one final opportunity to catch any major issues that might have been missed during the CR round(s) and to allow anyone who missed the CR round(s) a final opportunity to have their say. Revisions are expected after a CR round, but not after the FR. As the documentation explains:
https://github.com/dlang/DIPs/blob/master/docs/process-reviews.md
