https://issues.dlang.org/show_bug.cgi?id=20742
Issue ID: 20742 Summary: dmd -X (JSON output) includes uncompiled symbols Product: D Version: D2 Hardware: All OS: All Status: NEW Keywords: ddoc, json Severity: regression Priority: P1 Component: dmd Assignee: nob...@puremagic.com Reporter: schvei...@yahoo.com --- a.d version(Showme) private struct X {} version(none) struct Y {} --- dmd -X -c a.d cat a.json [ { "kind" : "module", "file" : "a.d", "members" : [ { "name" : "X", "kind" : "struct", "line" : 1, "char" : 25, "members" : [] }, { "name" : "Y", "kind" : "struct", "line" : 2, "char" : 15, "members" : [] } ] } ] ----- dmd -c -X -version=Showme a.d cat a.json [ { "kind" : "module", "file" : "a.d", "members" : [ { "name" : "X", "kind" : "struct", "protection" : "private", "line" : 1, "char" : 25, "members" : [] }, { "name" : "X", "kind" : "struct", "protection" : "private", "line" : 1, "char" : 25, "members" : [] }, { "name" : "Y", "kind" : "struct", "line" : 2, "char" : 15, "members" : [] } ] } ] ---- Note a few things here: 1. The "private" is not shown for X unless the struct is included, which makes it doubly bad. 2. The when the version is selected, it comes out twice 3. There is no way to turn on version(none). This is wreaking havoc with ddox-like tools that depend on the json file (yes, versioned out documentation comes through too). I don't know the regression version, but at least 2.077.1 does not do this. --