On Friday, June 29, 2012 12:47:28 Namespace wrote:
> A friend of mine ask me why D's foreach isn't like C#
>
> Means, why is it like
> int[] arr = [1, 2, 3];
>
> foreach (int val; arr) {
>
> and not
> foreach (int val in arr) {
>
> which it is more intuitive.
>
> I could give him no clever answer to, so maybe someone here knows
> the reasons.
Probably because for uses ; rather than in. But it's a purely subjective
language design decision. Walter could have used : like Java does, and it
would have worked just as well. He decided to go with ;. On the whole, we was
basing D on C++, not C#, so he didn't copy what C# was doing syntactically for
anything AFAIK. Lots of stuff like this is going to vary from language to
language, and often the decisions are arbitrary and have nothing to do with
what other languages did or are based completely on the lanugage designer's
personal preferences. If there's no technical reason for going with one over
the other (and I'm not aware of one in this case), then it's up to the
language designer to make a choice on it which is going to be completely
subjective.
- Jonathan M Davis
