Having been around long enough to remember when the ability to call "foo()" as "foo" first appeared, I feel it necessary to point out that this was *not* in fact a deliberate design, but rather a sort of "accident" that arose out of D's first attempt at properties. It was the same "accident" loaded compiler release that gave us pseudo-members -- the precursors to UFCS.

The community discovered that these things were accepted by the compiler -- which was actually against the language spec at the time -- and further that the resulting code did the intuitively correct thing. Response to the "accidents" being generally positive, it was decided to work toward making them legitimate language features. Some flavor of @property (or of a certain other proposal which was a mimicry of C# properties... I was in that camp) has been in the plan ever since.

I find the ongoing debate/discussion of @property and -property to be... well, moot. But hey, I'm just one crazy among an army of crazies.

-- Chris NS

Reply via email to