On Saturday, 19 October 2013 at 07:39:36 UTC, Maxim Fomin wrote:
This is wrong. Compare safe D and C# in safe, checked mode (I suspect you tried to sell unchecked mode, unmanaged pointers and C++ code invocation as unsafe C# - there are also unsafe features like casts or unions in unsafe D, but this is irrelevant, we are comparing safe mode) and try to come up with examples of memory corruption in C#. At least I showed 4 cases of memory corruption, 4 cases of broken immutable, 2 cases of broken purity in safe D without casts, unions and unchekeced attributes of extern C (which is also hole in type system). So far, you provided only resentment that D was negatively compred with C#.
I would agree if: 1. most of the cases you provided were not compiler bugs. 2. C#'s safety didn't have a price. 3. C# had immutable, pure, etc.
