On Tue, 06 Oct 2009 20:01:01 +0400, Andrei Alexandrescu
<[email protected]> wrote:
Hello,
D currently allows defining class allocators and deallocators. They have
a number of problems that make them unsuitable for D 2.0. The most
obvious issue is that D 2.0 will _not_ conflate destruction with
deallocation anymore: invoking delete against an object will call
~this() against it but will not recycle its memory. In contrast, class
deallocators are designed around the idea that invoking delete calls the
destructor and also deallocates memory.
So I'm thinking of removing at least class deallocators from the
language. Class allocators may be marginally and occasionally useful if
the user takes the matter of deallocation in her own hands.
A much better way to handle custom allocation of classes would be in the
standard library.
What do you think?
Andrei
I think it's okay, but I have a few points to discuss:
- Is it worth a keyword (delete) just as a shortcut for obj.__dtor();?
- I believe __ctor and __dtor (and __traits, too) are ugly reserved
identifiers.
- It's often useful to distinguish between dtor being called by user and a
dtor being called by a GC.
In the latter case you can't dereference any reference since they might
be invalid.
- How about object.d provides an IDisposable (or something like this)
interface which defines a void dispose(bool finalizing); and we get rid of
~this/__dtor entirely?
- obj.__ctor() is mostly used as a placement new. A new placement new
mechanism would allow drop that identifier, too.
- D has 2 placement new mechanisms for a struct, that are absolutely the
same (but different in syntax):
Foo foo1 = void;
Foo foo2 = void;
foo1 = Foo(); // indirect
foo2.__ctor(); // direct
The latter one could also be used for class initialization, but not the
former one.
You once announced an idea of dropping the 'new' keyword altogether and
make the former case also valid for classes. What's about it now?
- Could you elaborate on "a much better way to handle custom allocation of
classes ... in the standard library"? An example would be very appreciated.