dsimcha wrote:
== Quote from Andrei Alexandrescu ([email protected])'s article
I just wrote this to Sean and Walter and subsequently discussed it with
Walter. Walter thinks this should work. Does anyone have the time and
inclination to test this out? It would involve hacking into druntime's
implementation of ~= (I'm not sure what the function name is). I'd
really appreciate this; I'm overloaded as it is.
==================
In wake of the recent demise of T[new], I was thinking of finding ways
of making ~= efficient for T[].
Currently ~= is slow because accessing GC.sizeOf(void*) acquires a
global lock and generally must figure out a lot of things about the
pointer to make a decision.
Also, ~= is dangerous because it allows slices to stomp over other slices.
I was thinking of solving these issues by keeping an LRU (Least Recently
Used) cache inside the implementation of ~=. The LRU would only have a
few entries (4-8) and would store the parameters of the last ~= calls,
and their cached capacities.
So whenever code calls arr ~= b, the LRU is searched first. If the
system finds "arr" (both bounds) in the LRU, that means the cached
capacity is correct and can solve the matter without an actual trip to
the GC at all! Otherwise, do the deed and cache the new slice and the
new capacity.
This also solves the lack of safety: if you request a growth on an array
you just grew, it's impossible to have a valid slice beyond that array.
This LRU would allow us to keep the slice API as it currently is, and
also at excellent efficiency.
What do you think?
Andrei
1. I assume the LRU cache would be thread-local, so no lock would be necessary?
Yes.
2. I don't understand how this solves the safety problem:
It's rather subtle. I'd figured it out in the morning and forgot it by
the time I explained to Walter.
// foo lives on the heap b/c we've idup'd it.
string foo = "This is only a test.".idup;
string bar = foo[0..4];
bar ~= " is _not ";
writeln(foo); // prints "This is _not a test."
This is actually one of the less subtle cases. Upon the call to ~=, bar
is not in the LRU cache so ~= conservatively reallocates it.
As a rule of thumb (which takes care of the subtler issues): if a
growing slice is not found in the LRU cache, it will always be
conservatively reallocated. This is exactly because you don't know
whether that slice was reduced from a larger slice.
Having access to the capacity in an LRU cache doesn't help if I understand it
correctly.
3. I'm pretty familiar with these parts of druntime and would probably be
willing
to do the implementation after I understand a few details of it a little better.
That would be awesome!!!
Andrei