On Sun, Mar 14, 2010 at 21:29, Walter Bright <[email protected]>wrote:
> Philippe Sigaud wrote: > >> 1- thanks Walter for opening new vistas to me. Doing templated code >> in D is so fun and powerful that you transformed forever the way I >> look at problems. >> > > Years ago, although I had implemented templates for C++, I didn't "get" > them. Not at all. I didn't even plan to put templates in D, because they > seemed overly complex, ugly, and had little value. > That's interesting to know that you could implement templates, without understanding them. I eventually realized that what was preventing me from understanding C++ > templates was the syntax. Change the syntax, and what is happening suddenly > becomes obvious. > (snip) > Yes, it looks like a trivial change, and perhaps it is. But it makes a > world of difference, because it now looks like something I do get - a > parameter list to something. > That's my first 15' with D right there, Walter. It may be due to my not knowing what 'template' means in English at the time I was exposed to them in C++. But reading the D docs, it became clear that they were just 'potential code', waiting to be created, with parameters governing what could happen. > I had another epiphany from watching Scott Meyers give a presentation about > an application for templated type lists in C++. Nearly the full hour was > spent detailing a titanic struggle with the syntax. I suddenly realized that > the whole presentation would have been over in 5 minutes if the syntax of > type lists was simply that of an array of types. We already understand > arrays of values, so why should an array of types be any different? > Seconded, and thanks again for making that accessible. I was looking at Boost MPL (Meta-Programming Library) a few days ago, and thinking "How complicated the C++ syntax makes all this". I consider the MPL one of the most impressive part of Boost, but I don't think I'll ever use it. I have trouble extracting the intent among all the syntactic noise. Whereas in D, the first time I read some of Andrei's templates, (something akin to staticMap!(Unqual, Types)) the meaning was clear. The third 'leg' on which D templates rest is the alias parameters. I can have access to any symbol, including other templates? Oh yes! Philippe
