Re: Problems with D const ref vs C++ const &

[Andrei Alexandrescu]

On 12/10/10 9:48 AM, Craig Black wrote:
In C++ I could to the following:
Vector3 cross(const Vector3 &a, const Vector3 &b) { ... }

and then call it like this:

Vector3 a, b, c;
a = cross(b, c);
a = cross(b-a, c-a);

But in D I have to define two functions if I want pass by reference to
work:

Vector3 cross(ref const Vector3 a, ref const Vector3 b) {...}
Vector3 cross(Vector3 a, Vector3 b) {...}

Not having an l-value forces me to pass by value, and I have to define
two functions. I know about auto ref but that only works for templates,
and the compiler generates two functions which could lead to code bloat
if the function is a big one.

-Craig


auto ref should work for non-templates and generate only one function. 
The current implementation of auto ref originates in a misunderstanding.


Andrei