My point (and the reason I somehow hijacked this thread) is that such functionality would be useful for random access over narrow strings. Currently random access is missing.

Also this approach fits nicely if random access is needed to Unicode characters, not just code points.

I don't see much practical value in proposals to reconsider current string implementation. Arguments have been presented that it improves consistency, but as Andrei replied, consistency itself has many dimensions. Proposed changes have not been described in detail, but from what I understood, they would make common use cases more verbose.

In contrast, I do see value in Select / Rank indexing. Does anybody agree?


Reply via email to