Rick,

> To do simple test comparisons of the modes, I will bring up two software
> programs and visually see how the print compares between the two.

Seems to be the only way to make a fair comparison Rick. I do the same thing 
here whether it's on-the-air or with the HF simulator running. The PC 
doesn't seem to mind when running as many as 5 digital mode programs at the 
same time.

Tony, K2MO

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Rick W" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: <[email protected]>
Sent: Monday, September 29, 2008 7:22 PM
Subject: [digitalradio] Comparing data modes


> To do simple test comparisons of the modes, I will bring up two software
> programs and visually see how the print compares between the two. The
> main comparisons have been between Multipsk, HRD/DM780, and fldigi. For
> most of these tests I have been using my emachines tower with Intel 2.93
> GHz running Windows XP.
>
> I also have an HP Pavilion tower with AMD 4600+ chip running Vista and
> have been using it primarily for tests with my SignaLinkUSB interface to
> my ICOM IC-7000, which also allows me to have two digital data stations
> in the shack to perform ARQ testing with NBEMS. I can not view both
> computers at the same time since I use a KVM switch to work between them.
>
> I have not been able to see any situations where one program is clearly
> superior to another in decoding the signals.
>
>
> 73,
>
> Rick, KV9U
>
>
>
>> Rick previously had written:
>>
>>
>>> When I have done some crude comparisons with actual off air tests
>>> between different programs, there is usually not a lot of difference
>>>
>> Tony wrote:
>>
>> I'm interested in your test method.
>>
>> Tony, K2MO
>>
>>
>
> 

Reply via email to