No need to apologize for starting a debate.  If this label is going to
define our organization for the next 12 months, it's important that we
choose it carefully.

I actually agree that the idea of openness might not fit with the prestige
and elitism of major universities.  In fact, I've never been quite sure why
some of the most elite schools agreed to adopt open educational resources
(open courseware).  It can't be to increase exposure or applications -- why
would schools like Stanford, Berkeley, and MIT need exposure?  Maybe it
helps to raise the profile level of some professors.  I always assume,
though, that OER was partially motivated by a sense of supporting the public
good.  I assumed these schools had come to the conclusion that people would
enroll simply for the value of the degree even if many of the courses were
available online.  Therefore, they were not losing anything by making
resources available.  At the same time, the public could benefit greatly
from access to the resources.

If this is really the reasoning behind OER, then the argument for our
OpenUniversity campaign should be analogous.  Do other people have different
takes on the motivation for campuses to adopt these policies?

\Wm


On Wed, Oct 15, 2008 at 11:08 PM, Christina Xu <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> I'm admitting right now that I haven't read anything on this thread, but
> I'm going to throw in my 2 cents anyway. Sorry if they are redundant!
>
> I'm slightly unsure about the use of the word "open," and I'm not sure I
> agree with Will on Wikipedia's connotation being a good thing for us. I
> recognize that this may start a huge debate about semantics and I am so, so
> sorry about that pre-emptively, but here are my reasons:
> 1) This certification system is only going to be powerful if the
> universities eventually want it. It's all well and good to say that SFFC is
> powerful because we have chapters everywhere, but universities don't just
> succumb to peer pressure--they only want to emulate other universities that
> they respect, or gain honors that are prestigious. If we don't work HARD on
> getting the universities to understand why this Open University
> certification thing is important for them to work towards, it'll just be a
> metric and not an achievement: something useful for gauging the current
> status of things, but not ultimately that helpful for influencing
> universities to do the right thing.
> 2) Using the word "open" and rhetorics of open-door are not necessarily
> helpful in this cause. Like it or not, universities are economic entities in
> addition to institutions that serve the public, and this means that they
> have their own interests at heart. Like it or not, universities (at least
> many of the ones we're working with) are also somewhat elitist by nature,
> only they call it "selecting for excellence." They pride themselves on
> taking only the best and for having high standards, and this "they" is not
> just the administrators, it's also the teachers and students. This means
> that we have to be extra careful when throwing around phrases like "no entry
> requirements."
>
> Of course, I'm extra cautious of this because I happen to go to Harvard and
> I've seen these arguments come up even when discussing issues as seemingly
> clear-cut as open courseware. But it's not a problem that only exists here:
> in fact, many "mid-tier" colleges are even more careful of their reputation
> because they're trying to climb up that stupid US News college ranking. I'm
> not arguing that we shouldn't be bold in declaring our beliefs, but we
> should try to shape the message into one that's more empathetic towards the
> goals of the universities we're working with. Before we can convince
> universities to become more open, we have to make them understand why it's a
> good thing because traditionally, in this world, it hasn't necessarily been
> (or, at least, has had a bad rap).
>
> I'm in a post-debate daze right now, so I don't actually have any better
> suggestions, but I wanted to put this on the table before I forget. What do
> you guys think?
>
> Christina
>
>
> On Wed, Oct 15, 2008 at 11:00 PM, flurios <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
>> On Wed, Oct 15, 2008 at 6:31 PM, William Norton <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>> wrote:
>> > I actually like the connotation if the Wikipedia entry on the term is
>> > accurate:
>> >
>> > The term open university or open universities usually refers to a
>> university
>> > with an open-door academic policy, ie no entry requirements.
>> >
>> > This seems like exactly the meaning we're trying to convey: removing the
>> > walls from the walled garden.  We're giving those outside universities
>> > access to knowledge, technology, and learning tools as well as breaking
>> down
>> > walls within the university community in the form of proprietary
>> software
>> > and filtered internet access.
>> >
>> > And as far as trademark law is concerned, "OpenUniversity" should be
>> pretty
>> > safe.  The name of the university would likely be considered generic.
>>  Even
>> > if deemed simply descriptive we should be perfectly safe because
>> descriptive
>> > marks have weak protection.  Thus we would be more likely to be
>> successful
>> > on a fair use argument, if needed.  Also, the type of "service" we are
>> > producing is much different from an educational institution.  If we
>> combine
>> > the two words (i.e. OpenUniversity instead of Open University) and brand
>> it
>> > differently as the "OpenUniversity campaign," using dissimilar marks and
>> > logos, we shouldn't have any trouble.
>> >
>> I agree with what you wrote and I would stick with open university
>>
>> Cheers,
>> _______________________________________________
>> Discuss mailing list
>> [email protected]
>> http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss
>>
>>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Discuss mailing list
> [email protected]
> http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss
>
>
_______________________________________________
Discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss

Reply via email to