Rob wrote: > In my opinion the only thing worse than ambiguity is no > ambiguity, because lack of ambiguity never errs on the > side of Fair Use. ;-)
> Over the decades, Fair Dealing in the UK has been reduced > to little more than the right to give a positive review > for a work. Best practice guidelines, if adopted as a > requirement by insurers, may practically limit the general > scope of Fair Use. > It's a trade off, but as I say the real world experience > of Fair Dealing is that once you set an explicit limit it > is only ever made more limited.= Unfortunately, that's also the case when *not* setting limits. One of the considerations judges make when deciding on a fair use ruling is whether the use is in keeping with the norms of the relevant community. When people shy away from the gray areas of fair use, they're effectively abandoning them to permission culture. That's why the documentary filmmakers set up the standard they did. They planted a flag in much of that broad gray area and said, "This is explicitly okay." Just by doing so they helped to make it true -- at least for their own community. -=Steve=- -- Stephen H. Foerster http://hiresteve.com http://wikieducator.org/steve http://community.elearners.com/blogs/atsu/default.aspx _______________________________________________ Discuss mailing list [email protected] http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss
