*woops pasted in the middle of my last email.

This is a lot, let's see how well I can respond.

> I'm going to need some help working through this one.  I'm noticing this
> trend at Dartmouth that's bothering me:
>
> First, these guys cropped up:
> http://www.dartbarter.com/
> The idea is something like: "let's help students organize book
> reselling/bartering and ridesharing."  A service like this is something we
> /really/ need, being in the middle of nowhere.  Also, they're using
> PHPbb--a
> good ol' chunk of FLOSS.  I was excited!
>
> Then these guys cropped up:
> http://www.roundable.com/
> As far as I can tell, they have the same idea.  I have no idea what
> software
> they're using.
>

> But then I turned around and suddenly /both/ of these groups are trying to
> form meta-orgs, incorporate, and expand their service to other schools.
> Just recently, the Student Assembly emailed out an ad for Roundable,
> explaining that they were partnering to offer a free iPad promotion.
>

I saw a similar thing with this Stanford group: http://www.courserank.com
which is incorporated (though I'm not sure if/how they make money). Their
service is free--I presume they're having their recommender system learn
on the data and plan in the future to charge for use or sell the
algorithm(s) for other purposes?

Student Assemblies/Bodies across the country have embraced and advertised
CourseRank at their campuses, but again it's not so clear where it all is
headed.

It seems the plan for any web start-up these days is to think of some new
idea (or at least new take on an old idea), launch an app solid enough to
make a splash and get some press, incorporate somewhere along the way, and
sell to a bigger, stronger company (think Google, Microsoft, Amazon). Fat
wad of cash? Check. Resume explosion? Check. Ideological integrity? Well,
that's not so clear.

My guess is this is what these kids are thinking. Will it work? Maybe. Is
it a sustainable startup model? Again, not so clear.

> And now I'm really sad about this whole situation, and I can't quite put
> my
> finger on why.  I think it's uncool that the Student Assembly spammed the
> whole school with an email advertising a service provided by a private org
> (that happens to have been started by Dartmouth students).  If the SA gave
> them money, then I think it's doubly uncool.

I agree, the line between solicitation and support is rather blurry,
especially on college campuses.

>
> "But Parker, what's wrong with privately owned businesses?  Look, these
> guys
> should be using whatever type of organizational and business model lets
> them
> best provide their service to students.  Do you hate America?  Go back to
> blogging and eating vegetables."
>

lol

> You have a point.  And great FLOSS projects have meta-orgs (statusnet,
> mozilla found, wikimedia found, etc).  But at least those are nonprofits!
> The Dartmouth, our main newspaper, is also privately owned, but by a
> nonprofit.  Maybe this is common for college papers?
>
> I want to name practical problems with this commercialization and
> privatization, but I'm having a lot of trouble.  Can someone help me out
> here?  I want to say something like "they'll be less willing to release
> source code if they're hoping to make money by expanding to other
> schools,"
> but of course it's not impossible to build a business model off of FLOSS.
> Indeed, it's not impossible to serve in the public interest while making a
> profit.
>
> But, like, ugh.  I don't like this.  I thought that college was a rare and
> important opportunity to step just a little bit out of capitalism and
> build
> a community that we feel invested in and proud to be a part of.

FLOSS development has never purely been about altruism. Projects and
participants vary greatly in their motivations. However, student groups
and student service organizations have, to my knowledge, been very
altruistic.

I'm thinking about things like student food cooperatives, student
bookstores, and community-building/activist/political orgs (e.g. Free
Speech Movement to Students for Free Culture). All these groups exist to
serve and pursue their mission, but not to serve themselves other than to
accomplish the former. And in a way, I agree, student groups have the
benefit of stepping somewhat outside of a purely capitalist framework. It
seems, however, this is not necessarily the standard motivation today.

Maybe it's a good thing--some might say that applying these altruistic
practices to industry will help address problems more systemically and
will be more sustainable. On the other hand, at what cost will these
missions be made palpable--or dare I say it--marketable (even in merely
the normative sense)?

Today, student groups at Berkeley, if registered through the Associated
Students of the University of California (ASUC), technically fall under
the umbrella of the ASUC's 501(c)(3) nonprofit status. But there are
limitations even to being under a nonprofit! For example, nonprofits
cannot legally support/endorse political candidates. So it's not so clear
that student groups as they stand today are as free as we may think.

> Why can't
> we just build tech services for each-other because it scratches our own
> itch
> and is the neighbourly thing to do?
>

It seems like we can and will, but it's not what these two groups have in
mind.

> So help me out here.  I can't figure out how to sift through this issue.
> Does it have anything to do with Free Culture?  Am I just being a crazy
> communist?  Are there more compelling, practical arguments to be made
> here?
>

Yes! Yes! This has all to do with Free Culture, especially because Free
Culture is not merely about altruism (nor political ideology)--it is also
about measurably beneficial, reasonable practices that promote innovation,
diversify production, and increase access!

Perhaps there are two issues then. First, Free Culture is not as sexy as
getting your startup bought within 2 years of its inception. Second, it is
not so clear that student groups should stick to being altruistic or
political--there seem to be benefits as well as drawbacks.

> In the thread on Google Apps for Ed, someone mentioned the Open Computing
> Facility at Berkeley (http://www.ocf.berkeley.edu/).  They give students
> free email, web hosting, and printing.  I think that this really
> represents
> an ideal.

The OCF is a pretty remarkable mainstay of the Berkeley student group
ecosystem. But consider this selling point: students get to learn systems
administration by running one all themselves! That is quite a resume
booster, not too mention extremely fun if you're a CS nerd. Some students
seem to get involved for reasons other than access to technology and
home-grown student services. However, there are a good number of people
involved who do care about those issues.

> I'm going to start asking around seeing if I can stir up some
> interest in building something similar at Dartmouth.  I think that
> services
> like what DartBarter and Roundable are offering really ought to provided
> by
> something like Berkeley's OCF--a ragtag group of volunteers that just want
> to help make their school a better place.
>

I'm glad you are inspired by the OCF, and encourage you to do any work
that prizes access to technology and student services. However, perhaps
these groups aren't the "enemy." Maybe they are just like you but
misguided in this project and could use some thoughts and advice. Or, on
the other hand, maybe they have some perfectly reasonable logical
explanation that is above both of our heads. You should definitely find
out.

Keep us posted. Stay up.

- Matt

_______________________________________________
Discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss

Reply via email to