On 2013 Feb 17, at 15:44 , [email protected] wrote:

> Hi.
> 
> Would appreciate some views and comments here...
> 
> We're being pressured by our "Risk and Compliance" group to install antivirus 
> on our Unix (Solaris and AIX) and Linux (Red Hat / Centos) servers. 
> Historically we've not installed AV software on these platforms because there 
> haven't been viruses to worry about. I'm not sure that has changed, but we 
> need a better argument than "There are no Unix/Linux viruses" apparently.
> 
> So, I'd be interested in hearing if:
> 
> a) you run AV software on your Unix/Linux servers

No

> b) if not, have you had to argue it away?

Briefly only.

> c) if so, is this due to any external compliance issue

Both internal and external.

The simple response was "There is no antivirus software that exists to scan 
against viruses that attack Unix based systems."  Each one of the Linux based 
AV tools scans against Windows malware signatures only.  A few choice quotes 
from the vendors pointing out that they protected against Windows malware, and 
we put the burden back on the compliance team and pointed out that if we did 
this, we were still not compliant with what they were claiming we needed 
compliance with (malware protection for Unix based malware).  

It also helped when we pointed out "The AV software for "unix" doesn't run on 
half our Unix operating systems."  AIX was on that list.  Software may now be 
available, but it wasn't when we hunted (admittedly more than a few years ago).

Now, if they came back and said "we need to protect against Unix based systems 
being a vector to Windows", that we were prepared to deal with and investigate 
appropriate tools on those servers that could feasibly be a vector.  (SMB 
servers mainly for us, we relied on Exchange to handle Windows email).  

Knowing what they really are trying to protect, with the classic line of "Tell 
me your problem, not your desired solution" sometimes helps.  Of course, by the 
time you got here, you should already have a good relationship with your 
compliance team.  If not, that's a bigger problem.  Your interactions with them 
should be regular, proactively looking for problems, and you should be almost 
as familiar with policy as they are.


----
"The speed of communications is wondrous to behold. It is also true that 
speed can multiply the distribution of information that we know to be 
untrue." Edward R Murrow (1964)

Mark McCullough
[email protected]




_______________________________________________
Discuss mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.lopsa.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss
This list provided by the League of Professional System Administrators
 http://lopsa.org/

Reply via email to