I fully agree with the opinion expressed below by Dimitris.
Rather then asking nominated members to justify their
nomination and (harshly) stating that if they do not do
so they may not be good "champion of OSGeo", it
is for the present charter members who will be voting
to find out about suitability of each candidate and vote
appropriately. For me the information available at
http://wiki.osgeo.org/wiki/New_Member_Nominations_2011
and my limited knowledge of the OSGeo community
is adequate to make my choices.
Venka
On 2011/11/26 18:56, Dimitris Kotzinos wrote:
Dear all, Michael,
there are some things that for me do not sound well placed in the
nomination process, one of them is the request of the nominees to
present themselves in a greater audience.
Although I understand the request (and I find it perfectly normal and
logical because otherwise how would someone vote for one person never
heard of), I think that the idea is that someone is nominated because
of actions and contributions to the community - so the community
should know and moreover the charter members should follow more
closely the overall activities. Additionally I feel that people who
nominate others should be responsible to detail their contributions
along with the nomination. Since this is not a usual voting process
(where I submit a candidacy) I think it is not proper to nominate
someone and then ask him/her to "expose" him/herself.
Again not that there is something wrong with the request.
This brings me to a last point: maybe, as the organization expands,
this process needs a careful reconsideration towards enforcing either
a more open process (e.g. having all members to vote and the ability
to become candidates and not nominees) or a more strict process where
nominations should be followed be detailed CVs, etc. and possibly
having specific criteria to be met. Local chapters could also play a
role in this.
I acknowledge the fact that this can be a rather tedious and difficult
discussion but since I had the opportunity starting from Michael's
e-mail I thought to bring this up.
Apologies for the lengthy e-mail,
Best regards,
Dimitris Kotzinos
_______________________________________________
Discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/discuss
_______________________________________________
Discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/discuss
