For what it's worth...

I eagerly read that link you provided. It represents one end of the spectrum for values and principles in terms of open source. I believe it's fair to say that end of the spectrum is fairly staunch and recognized by some as radical and even marginalizing.

I believe there's plenty of room in the world for people who believe strongly in such messages, but I do feel personally this type of dogma seems a bit out of date and probably no longer as necessary.

The opportunity is for projects & companies partner and work together in harmony. For projects that are interested, there's help available. For those that don't want it, that's OK too.


On 07/27/2012 10:05 AM, Landon Blake wrote:
FYI: I release all of the code for my projects under the GPL and LGPL,
and have no plans on switching for my projects. So the licenses aren't
dead quite yet. :]

I think there is a tradeoff in the licensing decision between the
greater adoption that comes with a "weaker" license, and the stricter
adherence to open source principles that come with a "stronger"
license. (

I'm not making a statement about which license is better for OSGeo
Projects, I'm just making a general statement. I personally feel the
principles in the GPL and LGPL are more important than wider adoption
for my projects. But I'm just a hobby programmer.

There is one more thing to think about before changing the license on
a project. There may be programmers that favor contributions to
projects licensed under the GPL/LGPL, and consider a project's license
when determining where to dedicate their resources. I know OSGeo has
the right to change the licensing, but I believe there should be a
very strong case for doing so. It is, to a certain extent, changing
the rules after the game has started.


On Fri, Jul 27, 2012 at 6:22 AM, Mr. Puneet Kishor <> wrote:
On Jul 27, 2012, at 9:08 AM, Andrew Ross <> wrote:

BSD, MIT, Apache wouldn't have this issue - at the expense of not having the 
weak copyleft. Basically people can take the code and do what they wish with it.


Puneet Kishor

Discuss mailing list

Reply via email to