dean wrote:

> Slimserver is a bit aggressive about
> gathering song information. Users often
> have volumes that become unmounted and
> so we decided to let references persist
> in the hopes that those files will come
> back.

Features like this are great, but they should be made available as
options (e.g. 'Support removable media'). I'm sure the vast majority of
users are using fixed media for their library, so a feature like this
becomes more of a hindrance than a help.

Drastic changes in behavior need to be implemented cautiously and
sparingly.  For example, the new 'Browse Music Folder' and 'Browse
Playlists' functions are so vastly different from previous versions
(and severely broken, in my opinion) that they should have been
presented as options. A key rule in software design is 'never take
something away that was there before' (see
http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=15260 for examples). In
this case, instead of having to revert back to 6.0.2, I could have
simply turned off the option to use the new browse functionality and
still benefited from the other 6.1 enhancements/fixes. (Of course, if
the updated browse functions provided the exact same capabilities as
their previous counterparts but with the added performance benefits of
the new code, you wouldn't need to present it as an option at all. How
6.1 made it out the door with these functions in their current form is
somewhat puzzling.)


-- 
rds
_______________________________________________
Discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/lists/listinfo/discuss

Reply via email to