heinkraanen: I don't want to rain on your parade, but keep in mind these
NAS devices are not intended to run complex applications like
SlimServer.  They are not PCs and are not intended to have 3rd party
applications loaded onto them.

They'll fall in 3 categories:

1.  Full SlimServer support.  QNAP TS-101 and Infrant ReadyNAS.  Very
rare.  Limitations even on these: you have to wait for the manufacturer
to upgrade to a new SlimServer version (which contains the Squeezebox
firmware), limited plugin availability and restricted (QNAP) or no
(Infrant) transcoding.

2.  "Hackable" SlimServer support.  There's only one "open" NAS where
this is manufacturer-supported: the Kurobox.  On others, you'll have to
install 3rd party firmware to be able to install 3rd party applications.
This can be accomplished with varying degrees of difficulty, will
almost surely void your warranty and may "brick" your NAS if done
improperly (i.e. make it about as functional as a brick.)  Examples of
hackable NASes: Buffalo Linkstation, Linksys NSLU2.  More common than
category 1.

3.  No third party firmware.  You're on your own with these, and
manufacturers are unlikely to support you.  You can ask, but they will
probably say "what the heck is SlimServer?"  They may get 20 requests a
day for stuff they've never heard of before.  The vast majority of NAS
devices fall into this category.  Some of these devices may not even
run Linux but might run something proprietary like VxWorks, in which
case you're completely stuffed.  

While SlimServer can actually run on some pretty low-powered hardware,
it's complicated and needs Perl support.  Installing it on just any
embedded application like a NAS box is not a trivial undertaking -
remember, the manufacturers don't want you messing around in there. 
Again, these are not PCs and don't use conventional PC hardware and
technology - the OS isn't running off a hard disk but off flash memory,
there's no keyboard or monitor interface, the processor isn't very
powerful, etc.  All this makes modifying them hard, a lot harder than a
PC.

I don't mean to run this idea down, but you'll probably receive a
generic "we don't support 3rd party applications" from Freecom, which
is the standard response they give to the 10 SlimServer requests per
week, the 20 MythTV requests they get per week, the 40 iTunes requests
they get per week and the 2 "Billy Bob's super-duper Linux app"
requests they get per week.

You'd be much better off building a low-powered, fanless PC out of a
VIA mini-ITX fanless motherboard.  Or at the very least, go with
something that's been done before: Linksys NSLU2, Buffalo Linkstation,
QNAP, Infrant.

I don't want to sound mean, but unless you go with a device that has
3rd party firmware available or supports SlimServer right out of the
box you're wasting time.  There are lots of NAS boxes out there right
now, they're becoming quite popular, and you'll easily find hundreds
more if you look.  But only a very few can run SlimServer.

Again, I don't want to offend you but I think you're spinning your
wheels here.  A Google search for "networked attached storage" turns up
50 600 000 hits.  I bet 500-1000 of those are for NAS boxes.


-- 
Mark Lanctot
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mark Lanctot's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=2071
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=22820

_______________________________________________
Discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/lists/listinfo/discuss

Reply via email to