One thing I did not specify in my "directions" post was that I was using
Slimserver exclusively with MP3 files at the moment. So while the
behavior described (listing by ALBUMARTIST if present) is working, I
don't know for certain that it will work the same way for FLAC.

This tagging and setting method turns out to be the cleanest and most
straight forward to getting albums listed in the same order in both
Slimserver and iTunes.

Case in point:

Groove Armada's "The Dirty House Sessions." For all intents and
purposes, it is a compilation album, where all except two tracks are
from different artists (those two are by Groove Armada themselves).
Lately I have been doing all tagging in iTunes and have cleared the
COMPILATION tag and set ALBUMARTIST to "Groove Armada"

This will list the album as being by "Groove Armada" in both iTunes and
Slimserver. 

Slimserver will not list the individual artists when browsing by
artist. IMO, this is the correct behavior and doesn't need a setting.
If you set ALBUMARTIST it should override the track artist for the
display and sorting of the album unit, while showing the track artist
when looking at the individual track. There's not much point to that
tag if this weren't the case.

If I set the compilation tag, iTunes will list the album under "Various
Artists" regardless of the ALBUMARTIST setting. 

Now, iTunes has a bug in it that requires an additional tagging step
that has only been possible since 7.1. With the ALBUMARTIST tagged for
every track, the album will still not sort under that artist in iTunes.
Instead it gets sorted according to the name of the artist for the first
track. To fix this you have to change the TSOP (ARTISTSORT) for the
first track (or all tracks) to be the same as ALBUMARTIST - "Groove
Armada" in my example.

This may very well have broken in a recent nightly. I was having all
kinds of scanner issues with the nightlies last month so I reverted to
an older version from February. I will probably update sometime this
week and manually clean out all caches for a complete rescan to see
what's what.


-- 
MelonMonkey

Bruno
*'Twisted Melon - Fine Mac OS Software' (http://twistedmelon.com) |
'mira - Personal Control for your Apple Remote'
(http://twistedmelon.com)*
------------------------------------------------------------------------
MelonMonkey's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=8466
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=35854

_______________________________________________
discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/lists/listinfo/discuss

Reply via email to