Joerg Barfurth wrote:
Hi Peter,

Peter Hillier-Brook wrote:

I recently reported a Priority 2 bug in the OO.o 1.9.104 beta release (Issue #49865), occasioned by the severe loss of data in files containing several versions of a document. The problem was provoked by the conversion process to version 2 file formats (.sxw to .odt and .sxc to .ods) in that all versions of the document but the current one were discarded.



What is lacking is a file converter that converts sxw to odt files while 'preserving' older versions. If you need this, that is a new feature, so calling this an RFE is appropriate.

A better RFE would be ability to do a Save As... and not all of your version in the off-chance you just want to change the file name.


Now, why did I put 'preserving' into quotes? Because this requirement is still ambiguous, when conversion between different file formats are involved: what aspects do you want to preserve?

I don't think this is really nearly as ambiguous as you make it sound. The guy has a file with a bunch of version in it. It is currently .sxw. He want to be able to edit it as .odt file. It doesn't really matter if the old version are changed to .odt or not, because you can't edit them.

Make sense?

A more obvious approach would be to convert a versioned sxw file to an ordinary versioned odt file. But that would mean that the new file contains snapshots of 'versions' that never existed. Depending on the nature of the file formats involved (I don't know if we support any other versioned document formats beyond sx* and od*)

Calc has version in it, and I would assume the other component do to.


--
Peter Kupfer -- Using OOo since 'OO4 -- [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Want to help? http://www.oooauthors.org
For OOo tips: http://openoffice.peschtra.com/ooo_tips_tricks.html
To order OOo: http://openoffice.peschtra.com/distro/ooo_distro.html

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to