Colin Smith wrote:

Also, it is my understanding that Scott and Chris originally forked because of 
Manuel's (obvious) resistance to taking his project in an entirely new 
direction. Few if any bridges were burned. It most certainly was not an 'ego 
thing'.


I won't bother responding to most of this, but I will say this much. Someone emailed Manuel (m0n0wall founder and primary developer) and me (primary m0n0wall list poster and doc writer, as well as co-founder of this project) suggesting we merge the projects and not split efforts. Manuel replied before I got a chance to, and he's on the same page as us. Paraphrasing what Manuel said, the goals of the project are significantly different enough that it makes sense to keep them separate. m0n0wall's focus on embedded platforms leaves it with a file system that isn't suitable for a packaging system, and while it might change slightly for version 1.3, it will still not be suitable for most packages because it will never be a "normal" file system. Manuel is a stickler for doing things the *right* way, which is what has made m0n0wall a killer project. But that's also left a lot of users out in the cold, without the ability to do things they want or need to do. Manuel's stance is these things don't belong on a firewall (whatever they might be). And I agree. Things like ntop, various network management tools, and all kinds of similar things, don't belong on a firewall in an ideal network environment. But, when you look at a network that only has maybe 3-5 machines, or maybe even up to 10-20, segregating these services leaves you in a situation where you have more servers and administrative machines than end user machines (or at least an unacceptably expensive ratio). It's better to have these things on the firewall than to not have them at all, when you have no other feasible options (for non-technical reasons, usually cost). In short, Manuel agrees with what we're doing, we obviously agree with what we're doing, and there's absolutely no animosity between the projects, so there really isn't any room for argument.

Reply via email to