WGLC started on 2019-06-26. It ended 2019-07-17. 2019-06-26: WG Secretary called for additional discussion on three topics:
1. What further context is needed in the introduction 2. If explicit call outs to ICANN/limited operator capacity to implement are needed 3. If an np= tag is needed to allow PSD functioning for only NXDOMAINs By the end of the WGLC period, after a slow start, there was a vigorous discussion on all these issues and (with a few days post-WGLC for the np= tag discussion to finish) moved towards what was in my judgment a reasonably solid consensus. All issues that people brought up were addressed by the WG (including inclusion of some recommended editorial changes made before WGLC that hadn't made it into the draft). A new revision addressing the WGLC discussion (-05) and document shepherd comments was uploaded 2019-07-27. Post WGLC discussion: 2019-07-22: A question was brought up if the draft should include hard requirements to forbid mail from non-existent domains. The WG concluded that independent of the wisdom of such a rule, it was out of scope for the WG. 2019-07-27: A set of editorial nits were provided against -05. 2019-07-31: Additional document shepherd feedback based on revisions provided in -05 and earlier comments. 2019-08-09: New revision (-06) published fixing editorial nits and incorporating additional changes based on document shepherd feedback. 2019-08-10: Comments on -06 from Alessandro Vesely, but no suggested changes. 2019-08-13: Comments on the general PSD DMARC concept from Dave Crocker. 2019-09-03: WG Chair feedback on 2019-08-13 comments, some discussion ensues. 2019-09-09: Discussion concludes. It appears to me that the upshot of the discussion is that the Section 2.3 Longest PSD definition needs to be updated. All other issues have been addressed. 2019-09-24: Alessandro Vesely reports having implemented PSD DMARC in zdkimfilter for Courier MTA using an alternative data format for PSD DMARC participants based on the PSL format. Based on the post-WGLC discussion, I believe an updated draft before IETF last call is appropriate with three changes: 1. Updated Longest PSD definition: > 2.3. Longest PSD > > The longest PSD is the Organizational Domain with one label removed. 2. Addition of the PSL data format to Appendix B (it would be B.3). I haven't drafted text yet, but I don't expect it to be controverisial. 3. Add zdkimfilter to Appendix C (also didn't make text yet). Unless someone tells me otherwise, I plan to go ahead with those changes. Scott K _______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dmarc
