The latest draft continues to blur the rather substantive differences between the two tree walks. Important details get lost with no clear place to add the text needed to fix omissions. For example, the first tree walk terminates in four different ways, and each termination method has different wrap-up steps. Can that information be gleaned from the current document? Can you even find the right place for it to be inserted?
Organizational domain search and default policy search are described separately, as if they are independent activities, yet they are actually performed as a single step. I am not sure how we evolved to the current outline, but the one that I think we need looks like this: Tree Walk Process .1 Reasons for Tree Walk .2 Exact-match policy check and exact-match identifier processing .3 Organizational domain and default policy tree walk .3.1 Determine if tree walk is needed .3.2 Processing steps at each iteration .3.3 Termination and post-termination actions .4 Alignment check tree walk .4.1 Determine if tree walk is needed .4.2 Processing steps at each iteration .4.3 Termination and post-termination actions Doug Foster
_______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dmarc
